‘Craven virtue signaling’: Uproar as 43yo weightlifter Laurel Hubbard is set to become the first transgender athlete at Olympics
Fans have reacted with fury after Laurel Hubbard, a weightlifter who competed in men's competitions before transitioning in 2013, was announced as being in line to take on women at the Tokyo Olympic Games later this year.
The New Zealand Olympic Committee (NZOC) confirmed that Hubbard, who was the subject of a failed Australian weightlifting federation bid to ban her from participating in the 2018 Commonwealth Games, is "very likely" to be allocated a quota spot for the showpiece this summer.
Organizers added that the development had materialized because the International Weightlifting Federation (IWF) had amended its qualifying criteria as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, and a complex list of absentees from various countries has further increased Hubbard's chances of being at the games.
Laurel Hubbard, male weightlifter competing as a woman, "I don't think I'm any different from anyone else. I don't think I'm any tougher. I just do what I have to do." #SaveWomensSportspic.twitter.com/LKBizwP2eu— Save Women's Sports (@SaveWomensSport) March 1, 2021
Cheat set to make history at the Tokyo Olympics by stealing women's medals. https://t.co/i0sPQFJhMX— Kings Over Spotland (@KingsSpotland) May 6, 2021
The NZOC will provide slots based on athletes' potential to finish in the top 16 and threaten the top eight. Super-heavyweight Hubbard is currently 16th in the world rankings and scooped silver at the 2017 world championships.
She has been eligible to compete in the Olympics since 2015, when the IOC allowed transgender athletes to compete as women providing their testosterone levels are below 10 nanomoles per litre for at least 12 months before their first competition.
The Guardian's failure to support women against these Cuckoos is a disgrace. There is nothing positive about this move. It's a craven bit of virtue-signalling that history will look back on without utter disbelief. And contempt.— Phil Sparkes (@starofstage) May 5, 2021
What’s the point— coffee hound (@VictoriaThoma17) May 6, 2021
The news was almost unanimously slated by readers, many of whom rushed to correct the headlines by branding Hubbard a "cheat" who had sought a place in the women's sport because she had struggled for success among men.
"There is nothing positive about this move," said one. "It's a craven bit of virtue-signaling that history will look back on with utter disbelief and contempt."
"Male not good enough for Male category dominates female sports" is the real headline.— Chloe (@hazzawizza) May 6, 2021
Others claimed that the move was a blow to competitors born as women, with one labeling it "nonsense" and a "war on women" as others even suggested rivals should boycott the competition.
"This is the problem: a woman will have already lost a chance to compete at the Olympics – the thing they will have sacrificed so much for," argued a critic in reply. "You can't ask other women to do the same."
The female weightlifters should boycott & change the course of this ‘making of history’.— MsFitzroy (@sukytookitoff) May 6, 2021
This is the problem, a woman will have already lost a chance to compete at the Olympics - the thing they will have sacrificed so much for. You cant ask other women to do the same— Victoria (@FreelanceMontag) May 6, 2021
The issue of potentially banning transgender athletes from competition has been a fierce topic of debate recently, with many US states blocking or passing legislation on trans college hopefuls taking part in female sports.
A number of lifters and coaches complained when Hubbard was due to compete at the Commonwealth Games, although she later withdrew through an injury that almost forced her to retire.
If anyone thinks that a person would be willing to change one’s gender just to win at sport clearly does not understand that individual’s struggles and is far too quick making small minded, bigoted judgements. Look at your own behaviours before casting such ugly aspersions ...— laurel Hubbard (@laurelHubbard11) February 5, 2021
Our individuality makes us special ... be special, but most of all learn to love everyone for their individuality ... don’t hate because you’re frightened of someone’s uniqueness 🙂 Peace and love to all 🙂— laurel Hubbard (@laurelHubbard11) February 5, 2021
Hubbard has been vocal about her career on her purported Twitter account, where she frequently tells the public of her wish to be refered to with the pronoun "they".
"If anyone thinks that a person would be willing to change one’s gender just to win at sport, they clearly do not understand that individual’s struggles and are far too quick to make small-minded, bigoted judgements," Hubbard said earlier this year, in between berating UK prime minister Boris Johnson as a "moron" and castigating British activist and commentator Nigel Farage.
I predict a close contest with a couple of failed attempts before winning with the narrowest of margins. Gold medal without dominating. PR exercise.— tex tucker (@earlylevel) May 5, 2021
I am absolutely sure this will happen. He might even take a silver— Woman 🌒 (@SerpentQueen135) May 6, 2021
"Look at your own behaviours before casting such ugly aspersions. Our individuality makes us special.
"Be special, but most of all learn to love everyone for their individuality.
The more this nonsense becomes mainstream, the more people will realise what is going on and it will end. Much as I disagree with this, it might just wake up the world to the war on women.— Chris the Parisian SuperBoomer (@ChrisBalchin4) May 6, 2021
In rugby, if you compete for one country, you cannot then represent another. It should be the same for biology.— Elli (@ElliGower8) May 6, 2021
"Don’t hate because you’re frightened of someone’s uniqueness. Peace and love to all."
Supporters of trans athletes competing in female sports have frequently pointed to the scarcity of transitioned competitors winning medals, but one commentor voiced fears that Hubbard's involvement would be used as a stunt to further the argument that no unfair competitive advantage is involved.
“However, her selection will sharply divide opinion between those who see it as an enormous step forward for trans athletes and others who insist she benefits from an unfair advantage.” pic.twitter.com/H434qor6CI— Kathryn Crappell (@katcrappell) May 6, 2021
What will be interesting is watching the TV pundits discussing the event......watch as these sporting stars and journalists like Gabby Logan, Denise Lewis and Michael Johnson try to seriously discuss the merits of this......— Sister Rosetta (@truethingmies) May 5, 2021
"I predict a close contest with a couple of failed attempts before winning with the narrowest of margins," they said.
"Gold medal without dominating. PR exercise."
Hey ho. At least eyes will be opened. pic.twitter.com/qteGdMXzqc— BornFabnotafab 🕷 (@msmerrythought) May 6, 2021
“But she is taking oestrogen”*cut to shot of Hubbard lifting three times the weight of the second place woman*— Duncan (@duncanm) May 5, 2021
A fellow cynic replied: "I am absolutely sure this will happen. He might even take a silver."
The NZOC said it expected the nomination and selection process to take place in June.Also on rt.com Campaigners claim sports ban would ‘erase’ transgender female athletes as veto fails by one vote despite Caitlyn Jenner support