‘Tinpot dictator’: UK health secretary pilloried for saying he would snitch on neighbors who snub Covid-19 guidelines
UK Health Secretary Matt Hancock has been accused of exhibiting symptoms of totalitarianism after declaring that he would call the cops on people who defy coronavirus rules and refuse to self-isolate.
In an interview with the BBC’s Andrew Marr, Hancock stood by the government’s threat of issuing exorbitant fines of up to £10,000 ($12,920) to anyone who fails to self-quarantine for 14 days after testing positive for coronavirus. The measure also applies to those who may have come in contact with infectious persons. The penalty will be in place from September 28.
Marr expressed doubts over how such a measure could be realistically enforced, noting that “surveillance” would be needed to ensure people stayed at home.
“Would you call the police on a neighbor?” Marr asked the health secretary.
“Yes, and for the self-isolation part, that is absolutely necessary because that is how we break the chains of transmission,” he replied.
The exchange sparked a furor on Twitter, with many observers noting that Hancock didn’t call the police when Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s special adviser Dominic Cummings broke lockdown rules that restricted non-essential travel.
Unless my neighbour was Dom Cummings in which case I would defend his rule breaking to the heights of absurdity then invite him to explain in Downing St rose garden.— John Wm Stephens FCCT (@john_stephens67) September 20, 2020
Health Secretary, Would you call the police in on a Prime Minister’s Advisor who’s failing to self-isolate?— Steven Keevil (@stevenkeevil) September 20, 2020
Observers argued that Hancock was advocating policies that would create a “slippery slope” leading to more invasive surveillance in the UK.
Not everyone trashed the minister’s comments, however. Some expressed support for Hancock’s approach to the health crisis, arguing that the public needed to be “responsible” in order to stop the spread of the virus.Also on rt.com UK Health Secretary refuses to rule out 2nd national lockdown, but it would be ‘last line of defense’
Hancock insisted on Sunday that a second national lockdown could be avoided if “everybody follows the rules,” but cautioned that the government was “prepared to take action if that’s what’s necessary.”
His pro-tattling position appears to clash with earlier comments from the prime minister, who warned against creating a “sneak culture” after Home Secretary Priti Patel vowed to tell on people congregating in groups larger than six.
Like this story? Share it with a friend!