‘The days of trusting our government are over’ – RT’s Afshin Rattansi on BBC Question Time
An audience member dove right into the Russia debate, asking: “How certain are you that the Salisbury attack was beyond doubt the responsibility of the Russian state?”
Labour's Shadow Brexit secretary Keir Starmer commended the UK Prime Minister Theresa May in his response, stating that May was correct in expelling Russian diplomats following the attack on ex-double agent Sergei Skripal, which left the former spy, his daughter Yulia and a police officer in serious condition in hospital.
Rattansi swooped on Starmer’s comments, stating: “This person to my right who has had close contact with the intelligence services says ‘only Russia had these chemicals,’” he said, pointing at Starmer.
“That’s something, given that Britain vetoed in the past few hours a UN Security Council resolution asking for an investigation into these atrocities in Wiltshire. Why did Britain veto that resolution? That’s interesting, isn’t it?"
Afshan Rattansi straight away exposing the hypocrisy of the British government. What a star #bbcqt— Vince Mince (@droleproletroll) March 15, 2018
Rattansi’s statement referred to a move made by the UK on Wednesday blocking a UN Security Council statement drafted by Russia which called for an "urgent and civilized" investigation into the poisoning of former double agent Skripal.
Continuing, RT presenter Rattansi turned on Starmer and the Labour Party. “Why is it that neo-con, neo-liberal Labour Party members continue to try and use WMDs to push us into war,” he said. “That is an implication, certainly, over what your leader Jeremy Corbyn has been saying.”
Host David Dimbleby interrupted, attempting to steer the conversation back to the audience member’s original question. “I’m sorry, we’re getting off the point,” Dimbleby said. “You were asked a very simple question by Paul Wilson, do him the honor of answering his question. ‘How certain are you that the Salisbury attack was beyond doubt the responsibility of the Russian state?’”
On the matter, Rattansi stated: “Even the prime minister said it was only highly likely, so it is not beyond reasonable doubt. We must have an urgent investigation.”
When asked for his personal opinion, Rattansi said “I really don’t know,” before quoting RT’s tagline: “In a sense, RT as a channel, Going Underground, we try and look at certainty and question more.
Regardless of what you think of @afshinrattansi or his employers, I'm afraid he's absolutely right when he suggests questioning everything. This government simply can't be trusted, they cover up scandals to protect themselves and the elite. #BBCQT— Rachael (@Rachael_Swindon) March 15, 2018
“We cannot believe our governments anymore like we used to, just because a prime minister stands up and says, ‘the security services have told us so.’ Those days are over.”
Social media was divided by Rattansi’s comments. While some praised the presenter, others attacked him and the TV channel he represents.
He's an embarrassment. As is anyone who supports his views, Eh George. BTW, how is your mate Saddam Hussain?— Anton Gaudi (@RoddyTriano) March 15, 2018
Sickening to hear @afshinrattansi lecture on anti semitism, given the anti semitic messages he has shared, and to claim Russia helping the people of Crimea when human rights abuses widespread- hope that @bbcquestiontime won't let such madness go unchallenged! #bbcqt panel— stellacreasy (@stellacreasy) March 15, 2018
Afshin Rattansi there with one of the finest #bbcqt speeches in the programmes history. Keir Starmer has had to change his name to Keep Stammering.— ¢яαιgтнєρι¢т (@craigthepict) March 15, 2018
The RT journalist thanked the BBC for inviting him on the program despite comments made from MP Sarah Wollaston calling for the other panelists to “walk out in disgust” over his involvement in the program.
Seriously, why is @bbcquestiontime giving a platform to RT, a mouthpiece for Putin? Russia has unleashed a nerve agent here in Britain & 3 people, including a police officer, have been fighting for their lives. Hope other panellists walk out in disgust https://t.co/ndFtxGYRbm— Sarah Wollaston MP (@sarahwollaston) March 14, 2018
“And can I just say thank you to the BBC for inviting me because the head of the liaison committee in Parliament, Sarah Wollaston MP, has told all the people on this panel to walk off,” he said. “That’s free speech in this country,” he added.
Wow, the very first words from the Russia Today / RT presenter are outright lies -he claimed that Sarah Wollaston told the other panelists to "Walk off."— Alastair Thompson (@AlastairJT) March 15, 2018
It just wasn't true.
Remember that the next time people say RT is trustable, their reps lie for any points possible.#BBCQTpic.twitter.com/zWzhU4tM0w
In turn, Starmer said: “I have not had a conversation with her, she has not spoken to me.” Rattansi replied: “She has tweeted that the entire panel should walk out, I never said she had spoken to you.”
u may wanna check out her tweets then, cos she kinda tweeted exactly that 😳#bbcqt— YOLO (@nina_mrs_mummy) March 15, 2018
Think your friends would be interested? Share this story!