UK govt ‘using’ Westminster terrorist attack to snatch more spying powers - ex-cybersecurity chief
Major General Jonathan Straw says ministers are trying to use the terrorist incident last Wednesday to push for handing security services more powers, despite the weak case for it.
His comments come after Home Secretary Amber Rudd said it is “completely unacceptable” that authorities cannot look at the encrypted social media messages of attacker Khalid Masood on platforms such as WhatsApp.
Masood was on the chat platform just minutes before his fatal assault on the streets surrounding Parliament.
Straw says unlocking such data will also allow other parties such as criminals and foreign spies to access it. He told the BBC legislating for such a move would not necessarily make it easier to stop future terrorist attacks.
He says if the government does push through laws to decode messages, terrorists would quickly use other secure methods of communicating.
“I think there’s a lot of politics at play here,” he said.
“There’s a debate in Parliament about the whole snooper’s charter [Investigatory Powers Act 2016] and the rights of the state and I think what they are trying to do is use this moment to nudge the debate more in their line.”
“The power will mutate and move on. We are aiming at a very fluid environment here. We are in real trouble if we apply blunt weapons to this, absolutist solutions,” he added.
The European Union’s presidency has also expressed concern about such a move. According to the Associated Press, Maltese Interior Minister Carmelo Abela said people’s privacy must be protected.
“There is a fine line here. We need to of course protect the privacy of the people, but we also have to protect the security of the people.”
Speaking to the BBC on Sunday, Rudd said there must be “no place for terrorists to hide.”
“We need to make sure organizations like WhatsApp, and there are plenty of others like that, don’t provide a secret place for terrorists to communicate with each other.
“In this situation we need to make sure our intelligence services have the ability to get into situations like encrypted WhatsApp.”
She hinted that the government could be prepared to create new laws on the matter, telling Sky News later: “I’m calling time on terrorists using social media as their platform … I’m giving them more than a ticking off.”
Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn told ITV on Sunday he did not necessarily back Rudd’s proposal for greater access for security services.
“There is a question of always balancing the right to know, the need to know with the right to privacy.
“I think it probably is [broadly right at the moment]. I’ve been concerned about giving too much unaccountable power to anybody in our society.”
The Investigatory Powers Act became law in November last year. It grants intelligence agencies the power to bulk collect and store citizens’ emails, text messages and internet data.