German MP gets blocked on social media, faces probe over anti-Muslim tweet
The outburst that landed Von Storch in hot water was a reaction to a post on Twitter from Cologne police. The department offered New Year greetings and linked safety information in a series of messages in German and other languages, but it was the post made in Arabic that prompted the MP’s outrage.
#PolizeiNRW#Köln#Leverkusen— Polizei NRW K (@polizei_nrw_k) December 31, 2017
تتمنى الشرطة في كولن لجميع الناس في منطقة كولن وليفركوزن والمدن الأخرى إحتفالاً سعيداً بعام 2018 الجديد.
https://t.co/G5erMWFNQyرأس السنة 2017 ـ لمزيد المعلومات: # pic.twitter.com/BGxs4Kew7K
“What the hell is going on in this country? How come an official NRW [North Rhine-Westphalia] police account tweets in Arabic? Do you intend to appease these barbaric gang-raping hordes of Muslim men in such a way?” von Storch, who is also a deputy head of the AfD faction in the German parliament and a member of the far-right party’s federal executive board, wrote on Twitter.
In response, Twitter shut down von Storch’s account for 12 hours and informed her that she had violated hate speech rules. That, however, did not stop the politician as she turned to Facebook to once again express her anger over the police tweet as well as over her ban on Twitter.
“Happy New Year! In a free country! Where everyone is allowed to call barbarians barbarians, even if they are Muslims,” she wrote, commenting on her previous statements. This time, she, however, specifically explained that she referred only to those Muslims, because of whom “we establish safe zones for the German women as the state is unable to offer protection against THESE barbarians outside of these tents any longer.”
This still eventually led her to being also briefly blocked on Facebook over violation of German law. Her post, however, was not removed this time. Von Storch then referred to the Facebook move as “censorship” and an “end of a state governed by the rule of law,” adding that Facebook “had already adjudged” her before any verdict has been issued by a German court.
Facebook hat mich nun auch zensiert.Das ist das Ende des Rechtstaates WEIL: @polizei_nrw_k erstattet Anzeige,StA muß nun Aufhebung Immunität prüfen,dann ermitteln,dann anklagen,dann Gerichtsverfahren,dann Urteil (mir schlottern die Knie😉).Aber Facebook hat schon geurteilt.q.e.d. pic.twitter.com/pMpKdduqSo— Beatrix von Storch (@Beatrix_vStorch) January 1, 2018
In the meantime, a spokeswoman of the Cologne police department told the German FAZ daily that police had indeed filed a criminal complaint against von Storch and the MP could now face a probe over public incitement of hatred.
The incident, however, also apparently also became a sort of a rallying call for the AfD politicians, who rushed to defend their fellow party member. The AfD parliamentary faction head, Alice Weidel, was apparently one of the first to express solidarity with von Storch on Twitter – only to be briefly banned as well, after writing that the German authorities “have submitted to the imported, marauding, groping, bruising, knife-stabbing migrant mobs.”
2018 beginnt mit #NetzDG-Zensur!— Dr. Alice Weidel (@Alice_Weidel) January 1, 2018
Unsere Behörden unterwerfen sich importierten, marodierenden, grapschenden, prügelnden, Messer stechenden Migrantenmobs.@Beatrix_vStorch kritisiert zu Recht, dass die 🇩🇪 Polizei auf Arabisch twittert - und wird gesperrt!https://t.co/1BA06D4eV0
The AfD alongside the two politicians then declared themselves to be the first “victims” of a new German law tackling hate speech in the internet, which came into force on January 1. The law advocated by the German Justice Minister Heiko Maas particularly envisages fines for social media networks amounting to €50 million ($56 million) if they fail to remove hateful content or fake news within 24 hours.
“Now, Alice Weidel also [has been] censored,” von Storch wrote on Twitter, commenting on the issue. “On the first day of the [Social Networks Enforcement Law], a head and a deputy head of the AfD parliamentary faction have been finished off,” she added.
Nun also auch @Alice_Weidel zensiert. Glückwünsche @HeikoMaas ! An Tag 1 des #NetzDG der Fraktionsvorsitzenden und der Stellvertreterin der #AfDimBundestag den Garaus gemacht. Frohes Neues Jahr! 🎈 https://t.co/CNx9el6KMx— Beatrix von Storch (@Beatrix_vStorch) January 2, 2018
“Attempts to censor Beatrix von Storch & Alice Weidel, the two leading AfD members in the Bundestag [the lower house of the German parliament] actually backfired,” the AfD wrote on its Twitter page, adding that the number of its followers on Twitter reached almost 100,000 while the number of those following its parliamentary faction’s page has risen to 10,000.
Die Zensurversuche vs. @Beatrix_vStorch & @Alice_Weidel, 2 Mitglieder des Vorstands der @AfDimBundestag, bewirken genau das Gegenteil:— Alternative für Deutschland 🇩🇪 (@AfD) January 1, 2018
~1⃣0⃣.0⃣0⃣0⃣ Follower für unsere Bundestagsfraktion & dieser Account ist auch bald sechsstellig!
Herzlichen Dank für Ihre große Solidarität! pic.twitter.com/DNWIxXXyF0
Support for the AfD has also come from right-wing populists from abroad. Geert Wilders, the head of the Dutch populist Party for Freedom, expressed his solidarity with von Storch and called on Twitter to “stop censoring.”
Iranians are fighting for their freedom.— Geert Wilders (@geertwilderspvv) January 1, 2018
Twitter is suspending ours.
Grant @AfD parliamentarian @Beatrix_vStorch and ex-muslim and cartoonist @BoschFawstin their freedom of speech @Twitter and stop censoring.#freedomofspeechhttps://t.co/z8cDDpwrKr
The public reaction to the incident on social media was mixed. While some people said that the MP was rightfully banned for being an “unabashed racist,” others accused Twitter of censorship and even argued in defense of her remarks.