Violence ingrained in American society
Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords and a number of others remain in serious or critical condition in a local hospital. The congresswoman was shot in the head from point blank range, but surgeons are optimistic about her recovery.
The incident has reignited the gun debate in America, with many asking whether or not the American gun crazed culture is to blame.
The US leads the world in gun ownership, with 90 guns per 100 people. Gun ownership and gun rights are one of, if not the most, talked about political issues. As a nation, the US falls far behind other developed nations in curtailing gun violence and gun related deaths. Over 30,000 Americas die annually due to gun violence and an estimated 200,000 more are injured.
David Swanson, the author of "War is a lie" said the problem is a question of American culture.
“Everything about our culture is just saturated with violence,” he said. “It’s a question of our culture loving violence.”
The ongoing war climate and continual attack nature is not a positive influence on the American psyche. Swanson explained that American policy internationally reflects downward onto American society as a whole and that in the current climate of economic disperse and inequality, the mentality of the nation is even more fragile.
“And, because we make guns so readily available the violence is more deadly. It’s an incredibly destructive state,” he explained.
Andy Worthington, a journalist and historian from the UK, explained that, as an outside observer, he and many Brits often wonder why America has yet to implement further controls on guns following a number of school shootings and other violent tragedies.
“We’re certainly looking on and going surely this time around the American people are going to say, we need to have some sort of control on this, and yet it never happens,” Worthington commented.
Blogger and filmmaker Danny Schechter noted that had congressional Republicans not allowed a ban on assault weapons to lapse in 2004 the weapon used in the attack would not have been available for purchase.
“The failure of the ban made that weapon legally available to this young man,” he said. “There are many cases like this that probably could have been prevented had we had regulations and laws in effect.”
In America access to guns is relatively easy; however the security state is keen on confiscating shampoo at security checkpoints in US airports.
Swanson explained there is an ongoing overtone of violence and Americans have become conditioned by war; all Americans are affected.
“Through the war machine we are educating people; through our criminal justice system and the death penalty we’re educating people through everything that our government does to handle problems and through everything that Hollywood movies tell us solve problems, we’re teaching people that violence is the answer, and of course, it isn’t,” he said.
However, it’s not just about eradicating guns, Worthington noted. “You can certainly start having decent and sensible people arguing for some type of control.”
Many have blamed violent and hate fueled political rhetoric for contributing to the problem. The US media, as a part of the political conversation, is keen to argue they are not a part of the problem, just a messenger.
“Clearly more can be done to educate people about these issues,” Schechter argued. “Our media in a sense does not encourage people to go out and shoot each another, but they, in a sense, do target various populations.”
He added; “They do have an impact. There have been a lot of studies about how the coarseness on TV encourages the sort of bullying that takes place in our schools and the violence in our communities. Whether it’s gangster rap or Hollywood violent movies, people tend to see, monkey see monkey do.
Swanson argued that under US law and international treaties there need to be a greater criminalization of speech that incites hostility and violence. And Worthington noted that in the US right wing media outlets often spread dangerous messages.
“It’s dangerous, it ought to be illegal,” argued Worthington.
Kevin Powell, the author of the book “Open letters to America” said Arizona alone is not the problem, Americans are the problem.
“We live in a culture that has this wild fascination and obsession with guns,” he said. “We’ve got to take a serious look at our country and do some very serious soul searching.”
However, radio host Adam Kokesh said the problem is too many people view this incident as political, when it is not. The issue at hand is one of mental health, not politics and not guns, he argued.
“Everything is political,” Powell contended.
Kokesh argued, “To make it an issue about guns or politics or any of that in the manifestation is to really take a very shallow misunderstanding look at it.”
Although mental issues are important, the mere fact guns are so easily accessible to those with mental issues is a problem and should be discussed, argued Powell.
“We need to talk about gun control,” he said. “That’s a political issue and you can’t ignore that.”
It’s not just about guns, argued Kokesh. Guns are just a mechanism. Focusing the conversation on guns loses sight of the real issues.
“He could have easily as just of gone to Wal-Mart and bought rat poisoning and poisoned a bunch of people and killed them with their food or water or some other thing. He could have gone and chocked a bunch of people one at a time,” Kokesh said.
But, he used a gun, that’s the point, argued Powell.