Tennessee vaccinations turn political: Democrats denounce state halting programs that Republicans say bypassed parents
After Republican lawmakers voiced concerns that Tennessee health authorities were directly targeting schoolchildren for Covid-19 vaccinations, the state halted the program – and came under fire from outraged Democrats.
The state Department of Health (TDH) is halting “adolescent outreach” for all vaccines, not just Covid-19, the Tennessean daily newspaper reported on Tuesday, citing “internal report and agency emails” they obtained. This includes Covid-19 vaccination drives on school property and reminders for teens to get their second dose of the jab.
SCOOP: Tennessee Department of Health halts all vaccine outreach to kids – not just for COVID-19, but all diseases – amid pressure from GOP. Staff ordered to remove the agency logo from any documents providing vaccine info to the public, per internal dox. https://t.co/PX0Rvpc6Ot— Brett Kelman (@BrettKelman) July 13, 2021
Postcards and reminder emails will be sent to parents, so that they won’t be “potentially interpreted as solicitation to minors,” according to a TDH report cited by the Nashville-based daily.
The decision was reportedly made by Health Commissioner Dr. Lisa Piercey personally, and comes after the Monday firing of Dr. Michelle Fiscus, which the paper described as “Tennessee's former top vaccine official.”
Fiscus claimed the decision was due to pressure from Republican state lawmakers who had embraced “misinformation” about Covid-19 vaccines. She also complained to CNN about a “toxic” environment at work.
Tennessee fired its vaccine chief over her memo supporting the vaccination of minors. The state then eliminated *all* vaccine outreach to minors shortly after.Dr. Michelle Fiscus: “Our leadership has been toxic to work under.” pic.twitter.com/TjrRTNhH6D— The Recount (@therecount) July 13, 2021
At a legislative hearing in June, some GOP lawmakers accused TDH of circumventing parents and pressuring minors to get the vaccine using the school environment. Some conservatives said Fiscus was pushing to vaccinate teens without parental knowledge or approval, using what is known as the Mature Minor Doctrine, which typically says children 15 or older can consent to medical treatment.
Thank you Tennessee Legislators! We have been on this for several weeks. CDC and TDOH were planning vaccination drives in night schools using Mature Minor Doctrine to vaccinate our kids without our permission. It’s easier for peers and teachers to pressure them. pic.twitter.com/yoI0nP6uVd— Jan Galt (@chump24042266) July 13, 2021
According to the Tennessean, TDH Chief Medical Officer Dr. Tim Jones told staff they should conduct “no proactive outreach regarding routine vaccines” and “no outreach whatsoever regarding the HPV [Human papillomavirus] vaccine.” All school vaccination information should come from the Department of Education instead.
The paper’s report caused widespread outrage among Democrats. Former first daughter turned public health advocate Chelsea Clinton called the policy change “horrifying” with potentially “tragic consequences,” and insisted there was “no reasonable or moral defense” of it.
“Trumpism and right-wing anti-science extremism is harming and killing Americans,” declared Mother Jones writer David Corn, while Howard Fineman of the Yale School of Medicine called Republicans “pro-death & anti-science.”
Physician head of Tennessee vaccine program fired because she was promoting vaccination.This is kafkaesque. Tennessee has only 38% fully vaccinated. Now with fastest growing outbreak in USA (400% increase over 2 weeks). Elected GOP in state are pro-death & anti-science. https://t.co/KK5iG3Fni9— (((Howard Forman))) (@thehowie) July 13, 2021
“Does Tennessee really want kids not to be vaccinated against measles, mumps or meningitis,” Congressman Ted Lieu (D-California) wondered on Twitter.
“We've governed by nut-jobs with the intellectual skill sets of five year olds on sugar highs,” lamented Obama administration staffer and Democrat candidate for Congress Christopher Hale, who pointed out the halting of outreach applies to polio vaccines as well.
“They're now, like, pro-polio?” tweeted MSNBC host Rachel Maddow.
Tennessee halted its polio vaccine outreach to children today.You heard that right—it's *polio* vaccine outreach. We've governed by nut-jobs with the intellectual skill sets of five year olds on sugar highs.— Christopher Hale (@chrisjollyhale) July 13, 2021
However, the CDC recommends polio vaccinations starting at two months, with subsequent doses through age six. Measles-Mumps-Rubella (MMR) vaccines are typically given starting at 12 months, while the CDC recommends meningitis shots starting at age 11. None of these would apply to school outreach to teens.
The Tenneseean report did include a statement by TDH spokesperson Sarah Tanksley, who said the agency was responding to “an intense national conversation that is affecting how many families evaluate vaccinations in general.”
“Tennessee is on solid footing when it comes to childhood immunizations and will continue to keep information and programming in place for parents,” Tanksley said. “We are simply mindful of how certain tactics could hurt that progress.”Also on rt.com California reverses policy banning maskless children from entering public schools, ending mandate hours after it began
Covid-19 vaccinations at schools are being discontinued in part because of low demand, she added, but also “out of an abundance of caution” because they were “perceived by some to give the wrong impression regarding parental consent.”
“While the location may change, the effort to vaccinate individuals who choose to receive it continues,” Tanksley said.
Think your friends would be interested? Share this story!