Media corrects Haspel’s alleged torture record (but it’s still full of torture)
In a correction published on Thursday and causing a wave of retractions in the media, ProPublica’s editor-in-chief, Stephen Engelberg, wrote that a February 2017 story detailing Haspel’s involvement in the CIA’s notorious “black site” torture program had wrongly stated that she supervised the waterboarding of Abu Zubaydah, a suspected Al-Qaeda leader, and later mocked the detainee’s suffering.
The highly cited ProPublica report had pinpointed Haspel as the “chief of base” at a CIA site in Thailand where Zubaydah faced interrogation in 2002.
However, former colleagues of Haspel contacted ProPublica and disputed this allegation, claiming that she did not arrive at the base until after the waterboarding of Zubaydah had ended. The news came in the wake of Haspel’s recent nomination as the director of the CIA.
“The awkward communications between officials barred from disclosing classified information and reporters trying to reveal secrets in which there is legitimate public interest can sometimes end in miscommunication,” Engelberg wrote. “None of this in any way excuses our mistakes.”
Engelberg stood by other claims made in the corrected report, including the revelation that Haspel played an active role in urging her superiors at the CIA to destroy videotape evidence of Zubaydah’s waterboarding. Congress launched an investigation into the tapes’ destruction in 2007.
In its own correction, the New York Times quoted an unnamed former senior CIA official who said Haspel did not become base chief until late October of 2002 – months after Zubaydah was waterboarded. But the paper doubled down on its assertion that Haspel was in charge of the CIA site when a different detainee, Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, was waterboarded three times.
An important correction. Good that @Propublica did the right thing.— Hina Shamsi (@HinaShamsi) March 16, 2018
Core concerns about Gina Haspel are still the same: her key early role in the CIA torture program, her involvement in destruction of torture evidence. This is why all the docs about her role need to be public https://t.co/otu3AID67e
ProPublica noted that her advocacy for shredding 92 incriminating videotapes, as well as the waterboarding of al-Nashiri, are “likely to be the focus of questions at her confirmation hearings.”
Currently holding the agency’s No. 2 job, Haspel was chosen last week by President Donald Trump to run the CIA. If her nomination is confirmed by Congress, Haspel will become the agency’s first female head. Critics say Haspel’s culpability in the secretive Bush-era torture should disqualify her from the position.
Haspel’s participation in the CIA’s black site program has been the subject of a high-profile lawsuit by a European rights group. In 2017, the non-profit European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights asked German federal prosecutors to issue an arrest warrant for Haspel if she visits Europe.
Think your friends would be interested? Share this story!