NY governor signs pro-Israel executive order to ‘blacklist’ BDS supporters
In a speech to The Harvard Club, Cuomo said New York would “lead by example.”
“We are also a place of action,” he continued. “We want to take immediate action because we want Israel to know that we’re on their side. If you boycott against Israel, New York will boycott you.”
The point of a boycott is that it is impossible to construe it as other than passive, civil disobedience. To criminalize it speaks volumes.— Aaron Bady (@zunguzungu) June 5, 2016
The executive order will instruct the Office of General Services to compile a list over the next six months of groups, businesses and individuals supporting the “Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions” (BDS) movement, according to Haaretz.
@NYGovCuomo This order is a serious reach. As a NY business owner, I will support the BDS movement. You can't tell me how to run my business— Cryin Johnson (@CryinJohnson) June 5, 2016
@NYGovCuomo History will put you in the same space as those who refused to boycott South Africa. Congrats!— Justin (@_JGR) June 5, 2016
After completion of the process, executive-branch companies will be required to distance themselves from any organization or person on the list.
“The State of New York will not permit its own investment activity to further the BDS campaign in any way, shape or form, whether directly or indirectly,” the order states.
Day 1 as a pro-BDS voice in New York under Czar Cuomo's anti-BDS executive order. The authorities have not yet knocked. Will update soon.— Midianite ارن (@IsmeeErin) June 6, 2016
Legal organizations have previously called attempts to push forward anti-BDS legislation “21st Century McCarthyism,” and warned that it would create a “blacklist” of human rights advocates, mirroring the treatment of those who campaigned against Apartheid in South Africa.
The Center for Constitutional Rights, National Lawyers Guild, the New York Civil Liberties Union and Palestinian Legal have continuously called anti-BDS pressure politically motivated and an attack on the freedom of speech.
The New York legislature attempted to push through an anti-boycott motion for months due to pressure from pro-Israel lobby groups, but was unsuccessful.
The latest move by Cuomo has widely been seen as an attempt to sidestep the legal process and implement the policy on his own, Salon reports.
Israel boycott: 33% of Americans, 40% of Brits in favor, Israeli UN ambassador cries foul https://t.co/TIfNLOXyOc— RT (@RT_com) May 31, 2016
Last month, an anti-boycott bill pending in the New York senate was revoked after more 100 organizations signed a letter to the Albany offices of all New York state assembly and senate members condemning the proposal, which they said would create “unconstitutional blacklists.”
Attorney Rahul Saksena told Salon back in January it was “frightening” that there could be state employees “scouring the internet for pro-BDS Facebook posts, tweets and news articles.”
“It’s 21st Century McCarthyism,” Saksena said at the time. “The government cannot punish individuals and entities because of their speech and political views.”
On Sunday, Cuomo signed the executive order after attending a parade “in solidarity with Israel.”
Right-wing organizations such as “StandWithUs” and Christian Zionist group “Christians United for Israel” and “Proclaiming Justice to the Nations” have continuously called on US politicians to pass anti-BDS legislation.
The latest move comes after California passed an anti-BDS bill in the first of many steps of the state’s legislative process in April.
Canada also passed an anti-boycott motion this year after a bill introduced by members of the Conservative Party gained popularity across the board.
The BDS movement has cost Israel’s economy an estimated $1.4 billion a year, according to the Financial Times.
A study by US think-tank, the Rand Corporation, however, says the number could be more than three times higher at $47 billion over 10 years.