News station sues after NYPD tries to charge $36k for bodycam footage
Courtney Gross, a reporter for cable station NY1, sent a FOIL request to the NYPD last April for 190 hours of unedited body-cam footage. The police department responded by saying that it could only provide the station with redacted footage, and even that would cost them $36,000.
Now the network is suing the police department in New York state court, saying that such a price was “excessive” and “effectively bars public access to information that FOIL is intended to guarantee” according to the suit filed in the Manhattan Supreme Court.
"Access to such information should not be thwarted by shrouding it with the cloak of secrecy or confidentiality," NY1 said in the lawsuit.
The NYPD, however, defended the $36,000 charge in a September letter to the network. It argued that the steep price tag was a result of the costs of paying someone to view, edit and process the footage, which would take an estimated 304 hours.
“The lowest paid NYPD employee with the skills required to prepare a redacted copy of the recordings is in the rank of police officer, and the cost of compensating a police officer is $120.00 per hour,” the letter said. “Multiplying $120.00 by 304 hours equals $36,480, which closely approximates the amount estimated by the [records access officer].”
It isn’t clear where the NYPD took such figures from, since a $120-an-hour wage would add up to a yearly income of about $250,000 a year for a 40-hour workweek – an amount far exceeding the salary of an average NYPD officer.
Gross argued that the purpose of the fee is to throw “a cloak of secrecy” over recorded police activity, and undercuts the purpose of FOIL, which is “to foster transparency and trust between government and the citizenry.”
The lawsuit comes at a time when body cameras are becoming more and more common items for officers around the country in an attempt to hold police departments accountable for abuses of authority.