Al Jazeera Islamabad bureau chief put on terror list by US
Top-secret national security documents obtained by The Intercept through former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden show that Ahmad Muaffaq Zaidan was the subject of American surveillance as recently as 2012.
In June of that year, the NSA produced a classified presentation in which Zaidan appears listed as a member of both Al-Qaeda and the Muslim Brotherhood.
Beneath his alleged affiliation with those groups, the NSA notes Zaidan also “works for Al Jazeera.” In the same slide, though, it also knows that the journalist is listed in TIDE: the “Terrorist Identities Datamart Environment” database maintained by the US.
NEW: US Govt designated prominent Al Jazeera journalist as "a Member of Al Qaeda" https://t.co/iOh3Pqj5Zz
— Glenn Greenwald (@ggreenwald) May 8, 2015
Speaking to The Intercept ahead of the outlet’s report on the slideshow, published Friday, Zaidan “absolutely” denied any membership with either Al-Qaeda or the Muslim Brotherhood, but acknowledged that his lengthy career in journalism has required him to view controversial figures throughout Afghanistan and Pakistan. Indeed, Zaidan interviewed bin Laden, the former Al-Qaeda leader, twice before the September 11, 2001 terror attacks and was later provided audio recordings through an apparent courier containing messages from the terrorist.
“For us to be able to inform the world, we have to be able to freely contact relevant figures in the public discourse, speak with people on the ground and gather critical information. Any hint of government surveillance that hinders this process is a violation of press freedom and harms the public’s right to know,” Zaidan told The Intercept. “To assert that myself, or any journalist, has any affiliation with any group on account of their contact book, phone call logs, or sources is an absurd distortion of the truth and a complete violation of the profession of journalism.”
He's known for interviewing the group's leadership, but "by that standard any journalist who spent time with Al Qaeda would be suspect.”
— Cora Currier (@coracurrier) May 8, 2015
A spokesman for Al Jazeera told The Intercept that the revelation concerning surveillance of Zaidan demonstrates “yet another attempt at using questionable techniques to target our journalists” and amounts to “a gross breach of press freedom.”
According to The Intercept, the NSA slides that provide the fodder for their latest article relate to a US program named SKYNET. Through that endeavor, the intelligence community takes the metadata of phone call records already collected in bulk and analyzes them to infer suspicious activity.
In a statement, the Committee to Protect Journalists said it was “deeply troubled” by the Intercept’s report, with Bob Dietz, CPJ’s Asia program coordinator, adding: “Coloring the legitimate newsgathering activities of a respected journalist as evidence of international terrorism risks chilling the vital work of the media.”
The slides published on Friday show that the NSA believed Zaidan was likely a member of Al Qaeda given that his movements, as revealed through metadata, resembled that of couriers used by the terrorist group. In the US, meanwhile, a federal appeals court ruled Thursday that the NSA was never authorized to collect metadata of American-placed phone calls pursuant to the government’s interpretation of a Patriot Act provision, also revealed through Snowden.