Metalloinvest links up with Rusal on Norilsk Nickel
After a Norilsk Nickel EGM voted on a new board on March 11, with the results to be known within 2 weeks, Usmanov confirmed that his stake in Norilsk would be transferred to Metalloinvest, which had reached agreement with Rusal on the need to push managerial efficiency at Norilsk Nickel.
“The board of Metalloinvest recently approved a plan to buy Norilsk shares. The 4 % of Norilsk that I have now will be transferred to Metalloinvest during the year. We have reached an agreement with the Rusal shareholders on alliance establishment aimed on development of Norilsk Nickel. We also support the policy of improving the efficiency of the company management in the interests of all shareholders of Norilsk Nickel, but not of a specific one.”
The comments come as the latest moves in a long running shareholder dispute between Rusal, on the one hand, and Norilsk Management and 30% Norilsk shareholder Interros, owned by Vladimir Potanin, on the other. The dispute which stretches back more than 3 years has seen a shareholder agreement brokered and collapse, last years AGM vote up a board which saw then 25% shareholder Interros, gain more seats than rival 25% shareholder Rusal, amidst claims of voting irregularities. Last October, another EGM saw Rusal fail to achieve numbers to force changes in the Board. There have been a number of proposals by both Rusal and Interros to buy out each others stake, and last December Norilsk reached an agreement to sell an 8% stake to Trafigura Baheer in circumstances which Rusal claimed had not been discussed at Norilsk Board level. A bid to buy out Rusal’s stake by Norilsk management was rejected in December, which saw Norilsk subsequently embark on a share buyback, which has been embroiled in legal action in the Carribean, the U.S., Britain and Russia. The March 11 EGM was called by Rusal. Last Friday Interros confirmed that it had increased its stake in Norilsk to 30%.
Usmanov said that the Norilsk shareholder dispute could be resolved by a merger of Norilsk Nickel, Metalloinvest and Rusal. He said he thinks a merger would be of benefit to all parties.
“The target is to establish a unique holding company with Rusal, Norilsk Nickel and Metalloinvest total integration and involvement. The holding together with non-ferrous metals production will be engaged in the extraction of iron ore. It is anticipated by everyone, and it is inevitable decision which should be taken immediately for company benefit and confidence of its shareholders.”
UniCredit analyst, Marat Gabbitov, says the desired holding could be in the interests of shareholders but doesn’t expect that the move will succeed given the 30% stake of Interros.
“In addition to product diversification, it would not have a blocking shareholder, as, for example, in Polymetal, which is positive for corporate management. But without the consent of Interros such a deal impossible.”
Troika Dialog analysts, Mikhail Stiskin, Sergey Donskoy, Irina Lapshina, Zaurbek Zhunisov and Stanislav Ermakov don’t believe Usmanov’s comments will change the likely new board composition at Norilsk.
“Apparently, Metalloinvest and Rusal will now work together to take control over Norilsk Nickel's board of Directors, and Rusal should be able to leverage Usmanov's political sway, as well as Metalloinvest's funding capacity in the case of open-market stock purchases. We still expect Interros and Norilsk Nickel's management to dominate the newly elected 13-seat board of Directors, and we think that Rusal and its nominated independents can receive only three or four seats, while Metalloinvest will obtain one seat. Alexander Voloshin is expected to become Board of Directors chairman.”