‘Colored’? IBM apologizes for eyebrow-raising race tags in job posting
“We do not use race or ethnicity in the hiring process and any responses we received to those questions will be deleted,” IBM's vice president of corporate communications Edward Barbini told the Washington Post. “Those questions were removed immediately when we became aware of the issue,” he added.
Barbini later contradicted himself by saying that the company had replaced the offending identifiers with contemporary terms like “Asian” and “Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander.”
“Colored”, “yellow” and “mulatto” were sprinkled among the more commonly-used racial identifiers like “Caucasian” and “black” in two drop-down menus forcing job seekers interested in an IBM design internship to specify their ethnicity – twice. The menus also included “Not a Brazil National” and “Not a South African National,” even though the job was based in the US.
.@ibm applied for a job on your career site. Aren’t these ethnic group labels a little antiquated? To make matters worse, I couldn’t submit my application w/o selecting an option. I ended up selecting “Yellow” and “Coloured.” @verge@NextShark@angryasianman#racism#ux#designpic.twitter.com/4YTS0uTssB— Rich (@RichParkNYC) February 18, 2019
When job applicant Rich Park tweeted a clip of the offending menu, IBM quickly blamed the “insensitive language” on an automatic translator (which doesn't bode well for a company that makes automatic translators) and promised it would be removed from the Brazilian recruiting site. The only problem? Park was in the US, applying for a US position.
Thank you. However, I am based in the United States and applied for a United States based role (NYC). In addition, nothing in the application process indicated that it was a Brazilian recruiting site.— Rich (@RichParkNYC) February 19, 2019
IBM claimed the menus were a relic of “local government requirements” in Brazil and South Africa. “Mulatto” – meaning a person of mixed European and African ancestry – has held on in a few pockets of Latin America, though according to Pew Global Research it is rarely used even there. “Colored,” however, was abolished as a legal designation when apartheid ended in South Africa and hasn't been used in decades.Also on rt.com AI can’t beat a human in a debate (yet), but give it time…
Think your friends would be interested? Share this story!