'Eco-terrorist' released from prison, as feds withheld evidence
McDavid, 37, was convicted in 2007 and has served nine years in prison for allegedly conspiring to bomb government and commercial targets near Sacramento - including the Nimbus Dam in northern California - he deemed detrimental to the environment.
— San Francisco News (@SFnewsnow) January 9, 2015
His prosecution was based on a paid government informant known as "Anna" who housed and fed McDavid and his co-defendants, encouraging them to plot illegal activities while using FBI surveillance equipment to relay their interactions back to authorities. Anna began working for the FBI at age 17 after writing a community college paper about infiltrating protest groups, according to the New York Times’ account of the settlement.
The more than 2,000 new documents regarding McDavid materialized
upon a Freedom of Information Act request. The cache included
letters between McDavid and Anna that were given to the FBI's
behavioral analysis unit for review. It also included a request
by the FBI for Anna to receive a polygraph examination -- which
never took place -- to determine her “veracity” before
“the expenditure of substantial efforts and money based on
McDavid’s attorneys called for his conviction to be vacated given the withheld information that could have strengthened the defense’s case. Federal prosecutors argued that “none of the omitted items were even remotely exculpatory.”
Yet, in the settlement approved by Judge Morrison C. England Jr. on Thursday, both sides agreed to McDavid’s immediate release “to avoid the expenses and risks of further litigation and to advance the interests of justice.”
“Today we corrected one of the most egregious injustices I have ever encountered in my legal career, if you consider being released after nine years of wrongful incarceration justice,” said Ben Rosenfeld, one of McDavid’s lawyers.
Pursuant to the agreement, McDavid pleaded guilty to a conspiracy charge and was sentenced to time served. Judge England then granted McDavid’s motion to vacate his original conviction and sentence of 235 months. McDavid waived all future civil claims.
"I’ve never heard of anything like this,” said US district judge about FBI hiding evidence in eco-terrorist case http://t.co/xQTbGdDLxg— Stanley's Mom (@whenpigsflyyy) January 9, 2015
The federal government downplayed the withheld evidence, which
was provided in November and December, according to the
“The nondisclosure was inadvertent, and the documents were produced to the defendant promptly after their discovery,” said Lauren Horwood, a spokeswoman for the US Attorneys’ office in Sacramento.
The FBI’s pursuit of McDavid came amid a punitive crackdown on “eco-terrorism” in a post-9/11 environment.
“McDavid’s homegrown brand of eco-terrorism is just as dangerous and insidious as international terrorism,” prosecutors wrote in a sentencing memorandum.
Anna testified that McDavid requested explosive recipes and had
threatened her life at least once.
The defense argued that she had entrapped McDavid, who had romantic interest in her, and, based on recordings heard in court, had repeatedly and aggressively pushed him and his co-defendants -- who were compelled to testify against McDavid in exchange for a reduced sentence -- to follow through with actions despite the group’s ultimate lack of initiative.
“She fomented the alleged conspiracy, literally herding defendants together from around the country for meetings, badgering them to form a plan, and mocking and berating them when they showed disinterest,” Rosenfeld and another McDavid lawyer, Mark R. Vermeulen, wrote last year.
RELATED: Watch 'The Big Picture' debate on who is called terrorist: