‘Inaccurate, divisive’: British TV show roasted after using gender of world leaders to explain contrasting Covid-19 death tolls
A British morning television show suffered a backlash from viewers after using unfair comparisons to suggest countries with female leaders have done a better job than their male counterparts to suppress coronavirus deaths.
Good Morning Britain (GMB) – an ITV program frequently fronted by Piers Morgan – asked its viewers on Wednesday whether women are better leaders, claiming “few countries” with females at the helm “have high coronavirus death rates.”
In an attempt to back up that claim, they produced a graphic with British PM Boris Johnson and US President Donald Trump together on one side with their countries’ large Covid-19 death tolls vs. the female leaders of New Zealand, Germany, Denmark, and Taiwan with their relatively low fatalities from the disease.
They suggested that women have the innate ability to show more empathy than men, which has helped them to make the right calls while fighting the outbreak.
ITV News graphic compares how male and female leaders have managed the pandemic pic.twitter.com/wzexZv3g9C— Chris McShane (@ChrisMcSh) May 27, 2020
The blunt measure to compare coronavirus deaths between female- and male-led countries, without giving weight to factors such as population size and density, angered many on social media.
Furthermore, the program’s selective analysis omitted Belgium, led by Prime Minister Sophie Wilmes, which has suffered terribly during the pandemic with one of the highest Covid-19 mortality rates in the world.
British author Peter Lloyd hit out at GMB for singling out gender as a possible explanation for the success or failure of governments around the world to deal with the deadly virus, saying, “you wouldn’t have the courage to ask the same question in reverse.”
During a debate on the issue, journalist Ella Whelan told GMB that stereotyping women as “nice” and “caring” is sexist, adding: “There’s this general sense that having a bit more lipstick in the room makes things better.”
Are women better leaders?'The way in which leaders act shouldn't be down to their gender.' Journalist @Ella_M_Whelan says stereotyping women as 'nice' and 'caring' is sexist and they should be treated as individuals and judged on individual actions. pic.twitter.com/9YhM7tTYGl— Good Morning Britain (@GMB) May 27, 2020
One commenter on Twitter accused the morning show of producing “inaccurate, divisive, prejudiced propaganda.” Others highlighted Canada and Australia as examples of countries led by men with comparatively low Covid-19 deaths.
Data published on Monday by the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) showed that the UK has recorded the highest Covid-19 deaths per million based on a seven-day rolling average (4.54), closely followed by Sweden, Brazil, and the US.Also on rt.com ‘Guard of dishonor’: VIDEO shows nurses & doctors giving ICY welcome to Belgian PM over govt’s Covid-19 response
Think your friends would be interested? Share this story!
Subscribe to RT newsletter to get stories the mainstream media won’t tell you.