UK military jets risk mid-air crash with airliner due to lack of safety systems – report
An annual report from the Military Activation Authority (MMA) said a collision between a Typhoon and a commercial jet was “improbable,” but could cause a “substantial” loss of life.
“Collision avoidance systems should be installed with full haste,” it said.
The Ministry of Defense said it was considering the installation of the potentially lifesaving equipment to its Typhoon fleet.
The report said a failure by the MoD to fit the aircraft with collision warning systems – ACAS – is “unsustainable.”
Air Chief Marshal Sir Andrew Pulford warned Defense Secretary Michael Fallon of the “dangers” posed by the Eurofighter Typhoon, which has not been fitted with an airborne collision warning system.
Last year, an inquiry reported that the lack of a collision warning system on two military aircraft, which collided over the Moray Firth in 2012, directly contributed to the crash. Three airmen died in the incident.
In the MAA's annual safety report, Air Marshall Garwood said: “Our aircraft now spend more time at medium level [above 3,000 feet] and this has increased the likelihood of a fast-jet conflict with commercial air traffic.”
“If the MoD elects not to fit an ACAS, the decision will need to be well documented and the risk held at the highest levels of defense.”
Responding to the report, an MoD spokesperson confirmed “a collision avoidance system is being fitted to the Tornado GR4,” the type of aircraft involved in the 2012 crash.
The spokesperson also said “planned upgrades” were proposed for the new F35 fleet.
“Air safety is at the core of all our aviation activity and we take very seriously our obligations to our people and the wider community to ensure that our activities are both as safe as reasonably practicable and comply with relevant policy and legislation,” the spokesperson said.
Scottish National Party (SNP) spokesman Angus Robertson MP, whose constituency hosts RAF Lossiemouth, said the MAA's report was “hugely damning” for the MoD.
“Twenty years after it was proven and recommended that these systems would save lives they remain to this day uninstalled,” he added.
The SNP spokesman said “it is clear” that the MoD has “learned no lessons.”