Hitting the reset button? French defense minister & top diplomat visit Moscow for talks
The French foreign and defense ministers are visiting Moscow together and holding talks with their Russian counterparts for the first time since 2012, signifying a thaw in relations that had grown cold in the intervening years.
Minister of the Armed Forces Florence Parly and Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian have met in the capital with Defense Minister Sergey Shoigu and Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov on Monday. On the agenda are geopolitical crises in Ukraine, the Persian Gulf, Syria, Venezuela, and North Korea, as well as international nuclear and space-weaponization issues.
Entretien téléphonique aujourd'hui avec Sergueï Choïgou, mon homologue russe. Ukraine, Golfe, Levant, RCA : nous avons évoqué les nombreux sujets qui seront au cœur de notre rencontre à Moscou lundi prochain, avec @JY_LeDrian et Sergueï Lavrov.— Florence Parly (@florence_parly) September 3, 2019
This is the second signal in less than a month that relations between Moscow and Paris might be warming up, after the visit by Russian President Vladimir Putin to his French counterpart Emmanuel Macron in late August at Bregancon. On that occasion, Macron called for a “new architecture of security and confidence” between the EU and Russia and said Moscow is “essential” to solving the crises in Iran, Ukraine and Syria, and to ongoing work on nuclear non-proliferation.
While this has set off speculation about a possible French ‘180’ in relation to Russia, there have been few tangible signs of such a turn until this meeting of the ministers, for the first time in years.Also on rt.com Is Europe coming around to Putin’s Munich warning, or is this yet another false dawn?
The last meeting in this format, with foreign and defense misters from the two countries getting behind the negotiations table, was held on October 31, 2012 in Paris. France had recently returned to NATO’s command structure in 2009, after more than forty years in self-imposed exile, but then-President Nicolas Sarkozy had also closed a deal to sell two Mistral-class helicopter carriers to Russia.
All that changed in February 2014, when protesters, backed by the US, violently took over power in Ukraine, shoving aside an agreement for peaceful resolution of political differences negotiated by French and German diplomats. The coup in Kiev set off revolts in several regions of Ukraine, including Crimea – which voted to return to Russia in March of that year.
The US and the UK led the charge to impose sanctions on Moscow over Crimea and pressured France to cancel the sale of the Mistrals, which had already been built to Russian specifications. Sarkozy’s successor, Francois Hollande, settled the dispute by agreeing to refund Moscow almost €900 million in August 2015.Also on rt.com France pays Russia €900mn compensation for Mistral warships - reports
Discussions between defense ministers Parly and Shoigu this time around will doubtless focus on some of the same issues – Ukraine in particular has been a focal point of Macron’s foreign policy, with the French president negotiating prisoner exchange and demilitarization initiatives with Putin at their meeting in Bregancon last month. However, Macron has also become the champion of a combined European army since Moscow and Paris last spoke at this level. Though talk of a continental military force is still just that –talk– the French leader did say late last month that only an alliance with Russia can produce “a true European strategy.” Given the rhetoric, Russia’s role within or vis-a-vis a European army could be up for discussion on Monday.
Monday’s meeting may help break the ice between Moscow and the West, who have locked horns over quite a few matters in recent years. Speaking following a meeting with Lavrov in July, German Foreign Minister Heiko Maas declared that “without Russia, we will not find answers to the pressing issues in global politics.” As with France, relations between Moscow and Berlin had been strained following the conflict in Ukraine.
Italy, which repeatedly advocated the easing of tensions with the Kremlin, voiced a similar position that same month. Speaking in Rome, Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte described EU restrictions as “sad,” and “not good for Russia, nor for the EU, nor for Italy.”
In facilitating the apparent thaw, Macron is again positioning himself as the world’s middleman. With US President Donald Trump questioning old alliances and embracing a more isolationist position in international affairs, and with Britain’s future relationship with Europe up in the air, French seems to be, once again, the Lingua Franca of diplomacy.Also on rt.com Macron plays Russian card as part of strategy to place France at center of international stage
Pulling off a smoother G7 summit in Biarritz than Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau managed the year before, Macron took a gamble by inviting Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif at the last minute, with a view to saving the floundering 2015 Iran nuclear deal. The French leader has also appointed himself as global spokesman on the issue of climate change and an advocate for a ‘digital tax’ on Silicon Valley tech firms, clashing with the Trump administration on both issues.
Assuming the role of Europe’s chief negotiator with Moscow, therefore, is another step that Macron seems eager to take.
The schism between the West and Russia may be narrowing, but statements have yet to be followed up with action as European leaders remain guarded about embracing their neighbor to the east. Macron warned after last month’s G7 summit that “pushing Russia away from Europe is a profound strategic mistake.” Yet, days earlier US President Donald Trump’s suggestion that Moscow rejoin the G7 (turning it into G8 again) would also be a “strategic error.”
Reversing the trend of mutual mistrust would appear to be in the common interest, as Russia and Western countries surely are not lacking in international challenges to deal with.
Like this story? Share it with a friend!