'Netanyahu sacrifices literature for election votes' – banned Israel Prize judge
The Israel Prize, the Jewish state’s equivalent of the Noble Prize, was established in 1953 to award excellence in science and culture as well as honor individuals for their lifetime contribution to the nation.
But ahead of this year's award to be handed out in April, Netanyahu vetoed the appointment of three Israel Prize judges – Ariel Hirschfeld and Avner Holtzman for the Literature Prize panel and filmmaker Chaim Sharir – accusing them of "extremist and anti-Zionist" views.
"The situation in which a small and closed group, which holds extremist views, has control of the selection of the winners of the Israel Prize, must change," the prime minister wrote on his Facebook page.
The prime minister is also interim education minister and so has oversight over jury selection. Netanyahu said: "Over the years, more and more radical figures, including anti-Zionists – for example, those who support refusal to serve in the IDF – have been appointed to the panel and too few authentic representatives of other parts of the nation."
“I don't think the prime minister should be involved in such matters” as dismissing an award panel, Ariel Hirschfeld, a Hebrew literature professor at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, told RT.
He called Netanyahu’s actions “a blockade on culture” as the PM “tries to reshuffle all the rules, he tries to conduct the way the prize and things in culture will act in the future.”
Hirschfeld believes that the ban on the judges “has a lot to do with [the] election” on March 17, in which Netanyahu will try to retain his premiership.
The PM “thinks it is cool to shout again that all the intellectuals in Israel are leftists, and anti-Zionists, and he thinks he will gains some [votes],” the professor said. “I’m very sad he’s ready to sacrifice such a serious and important matter as literature for his personal interests.”
According to Hirschfeld, he and his colleagues had already started working when they received the news they had been fired from their positions on the panel by the prime minister’s office.
— RT (@RT_com) February 16, 2015
The trio of academics was told that the decision had been taken only after the scandal began making headlines newspapers, Hirschfield said.
Netanyahu wrote on Facebook that “he had to remove us because one of us, he did not say who, some years ago, [signed a petition] for the soldiers [who] refused to serve in the West Bank,” the professor said.
However, Hirschfeld believes the real reason for the ban “was quite personal” and that he was being punished for an article he “wrote half a year ago in the Haaretz newspaper against Netanyahu.”
The professor also refuted Netanyahu’s accusations, saying he’s neither “anti-Zionist” nor “extreme leftist.”
Haaretz newspaper columnist, Gideon Levy, told RT that Israeli right-wingers have been in power for two decades, but “still they feel they didn’t reach [sic] all the power positions in the country.”
The banning of the Israel Prize judges by Netanyahu was “about conquering one of the last outposts – and this is the intellectual lead which unfortunately are mainly lefties,” he said.
The ban on the three judges led to the remaining members resigning from the literature panel of the Israel Prize panel in solidarity.
Several famous authors, including Ruth Dayan, Haim Be’er, Sami Michael and David Grossman, also withdrew their candidacies from the award.
The backlash of criticism to Netanyahu's decision to remove the panel of judges forced his office to reverse a ban after an intervention by Attorney General Yehuda Weinstein.
This saw Hirschfeld and Holtzman returning to the panel, but three other judges who resigned announced on Monday that they don’t want anything to do with the Israel Prize anymore.