icon bookmark-bicon bookmarkicon cameraicon checkicon chevron downicon chevron lefticon chevron righticon chevron upicon closeicon v-compressicon downloadicon editicon v-expandicon fbicon fileicon filtericon flag ruicon full chevron downicon full chevron lefticon full chevron righticon full chevron upicon gpicon insicon mailicon moveicon-musicicon mutedicon nomutedicon okicon v-pauseicon v-playicon searchicon shareicon sign inicon sign upicon stepbackicon stepforicon swipe downicon tagicon tagsicon tgicon trashicon twicon vkicon yticon wticon fm

Warsaw’s step towards Polexit shows that West’s attempt to recreate Soviet Union in form of EU was doomed to failure

Paul Nuttall
Paul Nuttall

Paul A. Nuttall is a historian, author and a former politician. He was a Member of the European Parliament between 2009 and 2019 and was a prominent campaigner for Brexit.

Paul A. Nuttall is a historian, author and a former politician. He was a Member of the European Parliament between 2009 and 2019 and was a prominent campaigner for Brexit.

Warsaw’s step towards Polexit shows that West’s attempt to recreate Soviet Union in form of EU was doomed to failure
The Mexican standoff between Warsaw and Brussels has taken a turn for the worse as Poland's Constitutional Tribunal ruled that some EU laws are in direct conflict with the Polish Constitution.

This represents a direct challenge to the principle that EU law is supreme in its member states. 

The tribunal judgement on Thursday found that the EU institutions often “act beyond the scope of their competences.” Poland’s Minister of Justice Zbigniew Ziobro welcomed the ruling as it “set the constitutional limits of European integration and permissible EU interference in Polish cases.” 

Naturally, this judgement has provoked outrage in Brussels. The European Commission responded in typical robust fashion, stating that “All rulings by the European Court of Justice are binding on all Member States' authorities, including national courts.”

Moreover, the Commission made it clear that it would “not hesitate to make use of its powers under the treaties to safeguard the uniform application and integrity of union law.” In other words, Poland backs down or punishment is in the post.

Also on rt.com Poland does not accept being treated as ‘second class’, PM says after Warsaw rules its laws take superiority over Brussels’

And what will these punishments be? Well, as ever with the EU, the punishment will be financial reprisals. It’s a bit like when a naughty child has their pocket money withheld from an irate parent.

What gives Brussels the whip hand is the €57 billion Poland is due to receive in Recovery Funding. If the Polish government does not adhere to Brussels’ demands then this money could be withheld, which would blow a hole in Poland’s Covid recovery plans.

And believe me, Brussels will use this as a bargaining chip. As Jeroen Lenaers, a Dutch MEP from the European People’s Party said, “EU states must not stand by idly when the rule of law continues to be dismantled by the Polish government.”

The costs of being on the EU naughty step are racking up for Poland. Only last month, Poland was warned that if five of its regions did not reverse the decision to become ‘LGBT free zones’, then EU funds would be withheld.

Also on rt.com Polish LGBT dispute shows how a culture clash between West and East could sink the EU

Moreover, the European Court of Justice recently slapped Poland with a  €500,000 a day fine for refusing to close a mine that provides the country with 7% of the country’s electricity. You wouldn’t think Europe was in the middle of a self-inflicted energy crisis.

The problems, however, go far deeper than the odd threat and fine, as it is becoming increasingly clear that a number of central European countries are headed in one direction, and Brussels in another.

Whereas the EU craves power and control over its member states, these central European countries, which include Hungary, the Czech Republic, and Poland, want to see the ties loosened. Indeed, it is interesting that the countries that are now attempting to assert their judicial independence once lived under the yoke of the Soviet Union.

They remember what it is like to hand over sovereignty and have laws imposed from elsewhere; and they didn’t like it then and they don’t like it now, regardless of whether it comes from Moscow or Brussels.

It has always puzzled me why countries like Poland, which had fought so hard for independence from the Soviet Union, were prepared to hand over sovereignty to the European Union. I have always thought it a marriage of convenience and that trouble would come down the road.

Indeed, during one of my first TV appearances when I became an MEP in 2009, I told a Polish colleague that the European Union and the Soviet Union had a lot in common. Although he brushed it off at the time, I wonder if he still feels the same way now?

When I have made this argument over the years, I always referred back to a few quotes from the last General Secretary of the Soviet Union Mikhail Gorbachev as evidence. Gorbachev once said that “the most puzzling development in politics during the last decade is the apparent determination of Western European leaders to recreate the Soviet Union in Western Europe.” He also said that “the EU is old Soviet Union dressed in Western clothes.”

Nevertheless, Poland took a step towards Polexit yesterday, at least in the judicial sense. Now, like two cowboys in a spaghetti western, Warsaw and Brussels are staring each other down and waiting for the other to draw.

Also on rt.com Polish court finds some EU Treaty articles unconstitutional, but Brussels says its laws come first

My bet is that Brussels will shoot first. The EU can’t allow Poland to ride roughshod over its principles and laws, because if it does, and Poland is seen to get away with it, I guarantee that others will do the same.

However, one thing is for sure, this situation cannot go on forever. In the long term, only one of two things can happen: either the Polish government falls or is voted out in 2023, or Poland follows the UK out of the EU.

Like this story? Share it with a friend!

The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of RT.

Podcasts