icon bookmark-bicon bookmarkicon cameraicon checkicon chevron downicon chevron lefticon chevron righticon chevron upicon closeicon v-compressicon downloadicon editicon v-expandicon fbicon fileicon filtericon flag ruicon full chevron downicon full chevron lefticon full chevron righticon full chevron upicon gpicon insicon mailicon moveicon-musicicon mutedicon nomutedicon okicon v-pauseicon v-playicon searchicon shareicon sign inicon sign upicon stepbackicon stepforicon swipe downicon tagicon tagsicon tgicon trashicon twicon vkicon yticon wticon fm
30 Nov, 2022 21:44

Germany declares Soviet famine a 'genocide'

A Bundestag resolution says the label “obviously” fits the Stalin-era hunger, which Kiev calls the “Holodomor”
Germany declares Soviet famine a 'genocide'

The German parliament on Wednesday adopted a resolution declaring that the 1930s Soviet famine fits the historical and political classification of a “genocide." However, it restricted its condemnation to events in Ukraine, ignoring the fact that millions also died in Russia and Kazakhstan.

The resolution means Berlin should continue to support Kiev against Moscow, its authors said, without addressing the broader historical relevance of the issue.

Generally accepted estimates suggest that up to 3.9 million died in Ukraine, 3 million in Russia and 2 million in Kazakhstan during the hunger, which lasted from 1930-33. The deaths came during the forced collectivization of agriculture in the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin.

The Georgian-born leader was seeking to "liquidate" Kulaks as a class. They were land-owning peasants, who were largely based in Ukraine, southern Russia and Western Kazakhstan, in some of Europe's most fertile land.

Kiev has attempted to brand the period as "The Holodomor" and has conducted a long running propaganda campaign which falsely presents the famine as have beem exclusive to Ukraine.

“The mass deaths from starvation were not the result of failed harvests, but were the responsibility of the political leadership of the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin,” said the Bundestag press release. Referring to the 1930s famine by the Ukrainian term “Holodomor,” German MPs said it represented a “crime against humanity” and that from today’s perspective its “historical-political classification as genocide is obvious.”

According to the resolution, “in the winter of 1932/1933 alone, 3-3.5 million people starved to death in the Ukraine.” While “millions of people lost their lives as a result of politically induced famines” in other parts of the USSR, the authors insist the famine in Ukraine was a Soviet project to destroy “the Ukrainian way of life, language and culture.” 

The resolution requires the German government to “continue to decisively counteract any attempts to launch one-sided Russian historical narratives,” while providing “political support” to the Holodomor victims, meaning the government in Kiev.

Describing Ukraine as a victim of Russian aggression and imperialism, the Bundestag insists Germany should continue to give it “political, financial, humanitarian and military support.”

German MPs pointed to their own country’s “historical responsibility” for the Holocaust of European Jews and the “racist German war of annihilation” against the Soviet Union in justifying the bill. The resolution passed with a majority of votes from the ruling “traffic light” coalition and the opposition CDU, while the AfD and Die Linke MPs abstained.

The Bundestag resolution comes just days after Pope Francis called the famine “the genocide that Stalin committed against the Ukrainians,” which he claimed was “a historical antecedent of the [present] conflict.” His interview with an American Jesuit magazine drew condemnation from Moscow for racist characterizations of Muslim and Buddhist Russians.

While the government in Kiev has long claimed that the 1930s famine was a deliberate genocide of Ukrainians, as late as 2010 they were blaming Ukrainian communist officials for it and insisting there were “no claims” against any third party, including modern Russia.

Moscow’s position on the “Holodomor” has been that describing it as genocide is “politically charged and contradicts historical facts.”

Podcasts
0:00
26:13
0:00
30:34