Australia education minister raises specter of China & radical Islam during criticism of proposed history curriculum in schools
Australian Education Minister Alan Tudge has been accused of peddling “culture wars rubbish” after he said the country’s draft school curriculum offers a “negative view” of its history that impacts students’ desire to “defend it”.
The minister has waged a months-long campaign against portions of the proposed new curriculum – currently being reviewed by the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) – that, he claims, has “ideological misgivings” about the country.
During a speech on Friday, Tudge criticized revisions to the history syllabus as downplaying “matters core to who we are as a nation” and raised concerns that students would not “leave school with a love of country and a sense of optimism and hope”.
Describing a recent poll that showed “40% of young Australians” preferred a non-democratic system of government as a “catastrophe”, Tudge said there had “not been a more important time since the 1940s” to teach students the “origins, values and singular greatness of liberal democracy”.
“If students don’t learn this, they won’t defend it as previous generations did,” Tudge said, referencing the “growing” influence of “authoritarianism and communism” with the “rise of an assertive China”. He also seemingly cited the recent Taliban takeover of Afghanistan as evidence that “fundamentalist Islam remains a dominant force” in many countries.Also on rt.com Australia’s education minister concerned that proposed new school curriculum favors indigenous viewpoints over Western heritage
The minister had previously warned the history curriculum changes could result in students developing “a hatred” of Australia and said he did not want “students to be turned into activists”. In April, when public consultation on the draft curriculum began, Tudge said it should not “honor our indigenous history” at the “expense of dishonoring our Western heritage, which has made us the liberal democracy that we are today.”
A number of Tudge’s state counterparts criticized his comments, with Victorian education minister James Merlino labelling it “ham-fisted culture wars rubbish”. Merlino told Guardian Australia that it was important to expose students to a “variety of perspectives” about the country’s “both inspiring and incredibly challenging” history.
Meanwhile, Queensland’s education minister Grace Grace told the outlet that it was not helpful for Tudge to “provide a personal running commentary” on the curriculum while the independent ACARA review was ongoing.
Noting that she was looking forward to discussing the curriculum at a meeting of education ministers next month, Grace added that the final draft was yet to be put to education ministers. It needs to be approved by both Tudge and the state and territory education ministers before it can be implemented.Also on rt.com China tells Australia to ‘drop Cold War mentality and ideological prejudice’ after ex-PM Abbott visits Taiwan, pledging support
Prominent Australian historians have also blasted Tudge for “playing politics with Australian children”, warning that his campaign to make the national curriculum present the country’s history as having been “rosy and happy” was not helping give students an account of the past’s “complexity”.
Stating that “history is meant to be an accurate reflection of the past”, Melanie Oppenheimer, president of the Australian Historical Association, told The Sydney Morning Herald that Tudge was “asking [historians] to present something that’s just not true”.
Although Tudge noted that he had not seen the latest version of the draft curriculum, he said he had been briefed on some of the revisions and praised some improvements. He later tweeted that his assessment overall was that it had “gone from an F to a C, but Australian students deserve an A plus.”
Our curriculum must lift standards and teach kids how we became the wealthy, free, tolerant, egalitarian nation that we are. The current draft has improved from an F to a C.Australian kids need an A+ curriculum!https://t.co/3wZTvo3dC7— Alan Tudge (@AlanTudgeMP) October 21, 2021
If you like this story, share it with a friend!