Blame game: Internet giants shift responsibility on pirates
Published: 15 October, 2010, 22:57
Edited: 20 October, 2010, 17:32
TAGS: Crime, Russia, Law, Piracy, Internet, Information Technology, Prime Time Russia
Russia's leading Internet players are calling on lawmakers to make pirates, not providers, responsible for illegal downloads.
Five web giants, including Yandex and Google Russia, believe that individuals should take more responsibility for what they are uploading.
The companies demand more cooperation from copyright holders since, they say, it is too hard to control piracy alone. For example, sites like YouTube get 24 hours of video uploaded every minute, which they say is simply too much to monitor.
If there is a violation of a copyright, the companies will freeze the video or audio file in question but then direct the copyright holder to the person who actually uploaded it instead of getting involved themselves.
The giants also complain about the lack of appropriate legislation on the topic.
“The problem of responsibility for sharing copyrighted content isn't new,” Ekaterina Fadeeva, director of Yandex.ru’s legal department, told RT. “As it hasn't been decided on the legislative level, the courts have become decisive in such cases. But that's not the right path.”
Fadeeva says that the position of web giants is not opposed to that of copyright holders, and they are open for cooperation.
“We are open to dialogue and prefer not to use aggressive means to solve these problems. Some schemes have been working successfully for a while now. For example, when an author complains to a web platform that's hosting his material illegally, it gets deleted,”Fadeeva said.
For their part, copyright holders say that the companies intentionally create a comfortable environment for pirates. They believe that if the giants are making money on illegal downloads, they could at least share this money with the authors.
Meanwhile, Russia’s State Duma has recently adopted a bill stipulating far stricter licensing requirements for producers of optical media with content protected by copyright.
Expats get interested in Russian censusSchwarzenegger’s unforgettable visit to Moscow, the census currently going on in the country, and radical changes in Russian weather have attracted expats’ attention this week. |
18.10.2010, 11:42
6 comments
RT journalist shot and wounded in Moscow restaurantRT journalist Natalya Arkhiptseva was shot in the foot by a fellow customer in an upscale Moscow restaurant. |
Copyright should be for 5 years and no more, If you haven’t made your millions by then your not going too. History denotes this time and time again.
Wake up! its really boring listening to you lot dance around your handbags deciding weather to go for a pee or not.
I am with the ISPs and other Internet companies on this issue: they provide services but are not responsible for how their customers use those services. Nobody would suggest that telephone companies should be held responsible for customers making nuisance telephone calls or that automotive manufactures or car rental companies should be made responsible for their customers who break traffic laws whilst driving. There is no reason the Internet should be treated differently or that we should all be spied on merely on the pretext that some multimillionaire media moguls feel they might be missing some extra cash.












Some time ago, I really needed to buy a good car for my firm but I didn't have enough cash and couldn't buy anything. Thank God my colleague adviced to try to take the personal loans at trustworthy bank. Therefore, I did so and used to be happy with my car loan.