Medvedev calls for cutting the number of arrests
Published: 29 July, 2010, 21:21
Edited: 07 September, 2010, 21:55
TAGS: Crime, Russia, Human rights, Law, Prime Time Russia
President Medvedev has demanded to reduce the number of criminals in jails, claiming that more crimes should be punished using alternative punishments.
Basically, the aim is to reduce the number of people kept in Russia’s pretrial detention centers, the conditions of which came under heavy scrutiny in the late 2009 following the death of lawyer Sergey Magnitsky in a pre-detention center.
The situation is still rather serious: this week, Russia’s Ministry of Justice said that 233 people died last year in Russian prisons, and 277 the year before. Moreover, about half of all inmates have HIV, tuberculosis, syphilis, or a mental disorder as a result of the poor conditions they are kept in.
In order to tackle the issue, Medvedev suggested widening the list of suspects in minor offences who will not be held in pre-trial centers.
“Russia’s penal system is very complicated,” Medvedev said. “It evolved during well-known historic events. The Soviet period influenced it a lot. It’s really harsh and often unfair. So we have a problem of heritage. Our task now is to make this system more modern and effective.”
Medvedev did not specify what minor crimes he meant, but evidently he talked about economic crimes which, just six months ago, were downgraded from serious to non-serious status.
Since the measure was taken, Justice Minister Aleskandr Konovalov said, the number of people held in pre-trial detention centers has gone down by 20 per cent.
“Around 30 per cent of those placed in detention facilities are then usually excused or given alternative punishments,” human rights activist Valery Borshchev told RT. “Hence the investigation has sometimes used detention as means of pressure.”
Experts say Russia should stick to the US example, with 18 different preventative measures aside from holding people in pre-detention centers, such as house arrest and electronic tracking systems.
“This measure has been long called for,” Viktor Linnik, editor-in-chief of Slovo magazine, told RT. “Our penitentiary system is overcrowded. Obviously, it doesn’t do very well in terms of correcting people. So if there is a chance for some offenders to stay out of prison, this is exactly what we need.”
29.07.2010, 21:02
3 comments
Battle to save Khimki forest turns violentSome 100 people wearing masks attacked the local town hall calling for logging in the Khimki forest to stop. |
Luxembourg Embassy throws charity bash for woman with rare leukemiaThe Embassy has invited expats and Muscovites on a Roman Holiday to have fun and help a woman who is seriously ill. |
Again looking to US for examples? Idiots! The US has the highest percent of population imprisoned than any other country in the world. What you government officials want to turn the legal system and imprisonment into a billion dollar business? Cheap labor, prison contractors, and local support structures? That is extremely Orwellian. Try finding another example. Also again increasing education, middle class, and infrastructure decreases crime over time.












The problem is about penal legislation more than about punishment methods. The French are very similar to the Russians. There are also mafias in France, there is a high level of alcohol consumption, there are millions of immigrants, and the French are passionate people...Anyway there are just 100 immates per 100,000 popoulation in France, SIX times less than in Russia (600). Russians are NOT more violent than the French. Part of the difference is a consequence of the different level of economic development, so a fair number of immates per 100,000 population in Russian prisions coould be TWO or three times higher than in France, but not SIX times higher! And the level of criminality in France is lower than in Russia. So the difference must be legislative and thousands of people both inside prision and in the Russian society are suffering unnecessarily. Apart from being an impressive cost to the Government. In fact, the level of immates in Germany is so low (80 per 100,0000, SEVEN times lower than Russia´s) that Germany is renting prisions to neighboring states in the European Union. America has developed interesting punishment methods but its penal legislation is the worse in the World.