VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Opinion split over Libya attack  
MORE ON THE STORY
A Libyan woman holds a placard hailing French President Nicolas Sarkozy (AFP Photo / Patrick Baz) 19.03.2011, 10:04 8 comments

World powers hammering out Libya plan in Paris

Nicolas Sarkozy, David Cameron, Hillary Clinton, as well as representatives of the Arab League and UN chief Ban Ki-moon are meeting in Paris on Saturday to discuss UN-sanctioned military action in Libya.

Arab world protests Libyan conflict
Muammar Gaddafi (AFP Photo / Mahmud Turkia) 18.03.2011, 16:07 16 comments

Gaddafi lays down arms after air strike threat

Tripoli has submitted to the UN Security Council’s demands and declared a ceasefire. The move comes after several nations announced preparation for air strikes on Gaddafi’s troops, to which the UN resolution gave the green light.

Arab world protests
Tornado GR4 Strike aircraft (AFP Photo / Martyn Hayhow) 18.03.2011, 11:10 9 comments

International forces ready to strike Libya

An international military operation against Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi’s regime may start within hours. Libya's foreign minister says his country accepts the UN resolution for immediate ceasefire and will halt all military action.

Arab world protests
Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer USS Barry (DDG 52) launches a Tomahawk missile in support of Operation Odyssey Dawn on March 19, 2011 (AFP Photo / US Navy Visual News Service) 19.03.2011, 23:17 54 comments

Military push against Gaddafi in full swing

The top US military official said the no-fly zone has been established over Libya, following allied forces' strikes against Muammar Gaddafi's forces. Libyan officials claim 64 have been killed and 150 injured in the action, Reuters cited.

Arab world protests Libyan conflict

Opinion split over Libya attack

Published: 20 March, 2011, 12:52
Edited: 21 March, 2011, 04:08

A Libyan rebel fighter flashes the Victory sign in Benghazi on March 19, 2011 (AFP Photo / Patrick Baz)

A Libyan rebel fighter flashes the Victory sign in Benghazi on March 19, 2011 (AFP Photo / Patrick Baz)

TAGS: Conflict, UN, Africa, Sean Thomas, Libya, Gaddafi


Military action in Libya has prompted a spate of comments from world leaders and experts with many calling the attack a sham for the West’s self-seeking strategies and others backing the effort to protect Libyan civilians.

The African Union has called for an end to all military actions in Libya. Mohamed Ould Abdel Aziz, President of Mauritania, where the Union’s summit is currently being held, added that “the African Union rejects the idea of foreign military intervention in Libya, regardless of its form.”

Secretary-General of the Arab League, Amr Moussa, has also criticized the air strikes on Libya, saying they differ from the purported mission. Moussa called an emergency meeting of the League and said "what we want is civilians' protection, not shelling more civilians."

Meanwhile, Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Hamad bin Jassim al-Thani told Al Jazeera that Qatar will definitely participate in the military action in Libya.

We do not accept any harm coming to the Libyan people,” al-Thani said. “We are not targeting the Libyan people, or targeting even the Colonel [Gaddafi] or his sons, quite the opposite. How we can stop the bloodshed, this is our intention,” added the Qatari prime minister.

The fact that Arab countries are supporting the military action against Libya is quite important, believes Younes Abouyoub, a Middle East scholar at Columbia University.

If they don’t participate, this will look exactly the way Muammar Gaddafi has portrayed all this operation: that it’s basically a crusade, it’s colonialism coming back to Libya, and he would start using it to garner more support for his own tactics to fight this military intervention,” said Abouyoub.


embed video

Coalition forces stress their mission in Libya is strictly humanitarian. And Claude Moniquet from the European Strategic Intelligence and Security Centre believes that is what they should limit the operation to.

“We have to focus on one thing – the operation and ousting Mr. Gaddafi. To question what will happen in Libya after is clearly the problem of the Libyans.”


embed video

Michel Chossudovsky, director at the Center for Research on Globalization, also believes the operation in Libya is not a humanitarian mission, but an effort to overthrow Gaddafi.

The true fee of this war is oil, and France, Britain, United States, Canada are there with the intention of serving the interests of oil corporations and the extension of their influence into Africa,” Chossudovsky said.

This is not a humanitarian operation, it is a war of conquest, and it will have devastating consequences not only on the people of Libya, but more generally.


embed video

­Mark Almond, a professor of international relations, believes the intervention began because the opposition, which turned out to be a not very effective military force, could not continue fighting Gaddafi’s forces.

Gaddafi seems to have people ready to fight for him than are organized to fight on the other side, and that’s why NATO needed to try and turn the balance of power,” said Almond.


embed video

­War correspondent and former UN investigator Keith Harmon Snow says that although a genuine popular uprising is indeed a reason for the Libyan unrest, it is also being inflamed by many groups supported by the West.

This is really a very manipulated ‘conflict,’ and the people of Libya are going to suffer the most,” he said. “And it won’t be very long before the people, the true popular uprising, realizes that they have no control over their country because the United States, France, Italy and Britain have moved in again.


embed video

­Anti-war activist Jens Wagner says that no matter the outcome, we will not see democracy forming in Libya, as it is a stand-off situation.

And then they’ll have to divide the country, and probably the allied forces, United States, England, France, will be negotiating with the new government in the eastern part of Libya. But there’s also a great chance of a prolonged civil war,” said Wagner.


embed video

­There are still political possibilities to resolve the Libyan crisis without armed intervention, because the anti-Libyan coalition does not have a common understanding of what should be done during phase one of the operation, believes Benoit Calvi from the Peace Action Organization. He says while Americans have attacked some 20 military and infrastructural targets in Libya, “France, which is leading this attack, is doing its own things on the field, for example bombing tanks – which is not exactly appreciated by the coalition.”


embed video

­Ralph Schoenman, a radio host and anti-war activist, believes that NATO’s real motive for military intervention is not a desire to help Libyans in their uprising, but oil interests.

Every so-called humanitarian intervention, whether it’s in Somalia or whether it’s in the Congo, or whether it’s in Libya, has the intent of subjugating the population and seizing the resources,” said Schoenman.

And what they are above all concerned with is not only the outcome of the struggle of popular masses in Libya, but that which is unfolding in Tunisia and in Egypt, and across the region.


embed video

+3 (7 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Supporters of the Libyan rebels take part in a demonstration in Berlin on March 19, 2011 (AFP Photo / Soeren Stache / Germany Out) 20.03.2011, 11:33 6 comments

West and Arab world unanimously back assault on Libya

EU powers are now falling into line confirming their commitment to the operation against pro-Gaddafi forces in Libya.

Libyan conflict
This handout photo taken on March 14, 2011 and received on March 19, 2011 by the US Air Force shows an US Air Force search and rescue team in an HH-60 G Pave Hawk helicopter surveying the earthquake and tsunami damage as it flies over Sendai in Miyagi prefecture (AFP Photo / HO / US Air Force / Airman 1st Class Katrina R. Menchaca) 20.03.2011, 13:42 4 comments

High seismic activity will last 10 years – seismologist

The magnitude-9.0 earthquake in Japan was one of the major events in the natural cycle of the planet's seismic activity, Evgeny Rogozhin, deputy director of the Institute of Physics of the Earth of the Russian Academy of Sciences told RT.

Earthquake in Japan
Nicholas March 21, 2011, 21:55
0

If we do end up eating our criticism of proceedings, barring explicit objection to negative impacts and injuries against the natural rights of people to wholeness of body/mind etc. Will the sharpness of our fears be merely flung about to the next topic like a loose sack of potatoes or be sharpened as a weapon forged in the eternal blood of Libya?

Thulani Jili March 21, 2011, 20:50
0

Let's set the record straight. UN Resolution 1973 is now being abused by US, Britain and France. A no-fly zone is to protect civilians not to carry out air strikes as we have seen in the past few days. Further more, there's no consistancy in applying this resolution. When Gaza was under heavy artillery bombardment by Israeli, UN did not apply a no-fly zone, Bahrain is using army against its own people and UN is absolutely quite. Well done Russia, Germany, Brazil, India and China for abstaining because you genuinely love people of Libya (not necessarily Gaddafi) and you dont want to see Libya go in the direction of Iraq and Afganistan. Peaceful means are the key in this conflict.

The Old Man March 21, 2011, 16:21
0

PLEASE, PLEASE TRY AND SEE THE BIG AND LONG TERM PICTURE. Yes its obvious to even the dimmist and least informed that this is not a humanitarian opperation  but oil is not the main issue here either.

 

It is the easy and long-term access to the whole CONTINENT OF AFRICA which is at stake. For all intents and purposes Libya is just 'off the coast' of Europe and all this implies. Also, the US and Europeans are being 'outflanked' in Africa by China and some other notable countries (even Iran has a strong foothold). Libya has always been the perfect brighead into Africa for the great European powers. Today is no different.

 

An opportunity for regime change and the 'humanitarian occupation' of Libya due to internal conflict has arisen which was simply too good to miss.

 

I have been trying to get this message out for weeks - please RT print this and encourage people to think about it and discuss it. I want people to see what is really going on here.