VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Ukrainian political analyst under fire for views on 1930s famine  
MORE ON THE STORY
21.01.2010, 08:09 4 comments

Ukraine puts journalist on trial for viewpoint

A journalist is due to go on trial in Ukraine for challenging the official view of the 1930s famine in the country.

27.11.2009, 17:12 3 comments

Ukraine changes mind over Russia’s role in Stalin-era famine

Quite unexpectedly, top Ukrainian politicians have started making statements saying that Russia should not be blamed for the famine that claimed millions of lives in Ukraine in 1932-33.

Adolf Hitler (AFP Photo) 15.10.2010, 08:40 8 comments

10% of Germans want Führer back - survey

One in ten Germans would like to see a Führer in power; they see dictatorship as the best option for the country, a survey has revealed.

31.07.2010, 10:53 221 comments

Anti-fascists not welcome in Estonia

Estonian authorities have banned anti-fascist activists from entering the country. The activists were going to rally against the meeting of Estonian veterans who fought on the side of Nazi Germany.

Photo from www.deportationday.eu 28.01.2010, 05:21 46 comments

Lithuania opens Gulag prison camp for students

A recreated Stalin-era prison camp near Vilnius, a Gulag, has become a peculiar attraction for EU students. Each day some 40 young people spend the day as prisoners under the surveillance of stern guards.

Ukraine, Sevastopol: Pro-Russian supporters wave flags as they welcome missile cruiser Moskva, a flagship of Russian Black Sea Fleet, entering Sevastopol bay on September 10, 2008. (AFP Photo / Vasily Batanov) 30.04.2010, 09:35 9 comments

Russia’s Black Sea Fleet to remain in Sevastopol

On Thursday, the presidents of Russia and Ukraine, Dmitry Medvedev and Viktor Yanukovich, signed a law on ratification of the Agreement to extend the Black Sea Fleet’s presence in Crimea after 2017 for another 25 years.

Russian Federation, Moscow : Russian President Dmitry Medvedev (L) shakes hands with Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovich (R) at the Kremlin in Moscow on March 5, 2010. (AFP Photo / POOL / Natalia Kolesnikova) 05.03.2010, 16:15 8 comments

End of “bad streak” in Russian-Ukrainian relations - Medvedev

President Dmitry Medvedev said he hopes that with the election of Viktor Yanukovich, the “bad streak” in Russian-Ukrainian relations has finally come to an end.

Bodies of the passengers of the flight IR655 03.07.2010, 03:04 8 comments

22 years later, no apology for IR655

Twenty two years ago, 290 Iranian civilians were killed by an American navy ship, an incident the US has refused to apologize for.

Indian President Pratibha Devisingh Patil 14.03.2010, 10:16 9 comments

Women are less corrupt so put them in power

Women in India have long been sidelined from politics, but that could be about to change, with a new bill approved by the upper house of parliament this week on setting aside one third of the seats for women.

04.08.2010, 22:41 8 comments

Moscow calls on world to stop selling weapons to Georgia – official

Moscow insists that the international community should refrain from selling weaponry to Georgia, Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Grigory Karasin has said.

Ukrainian political analyst under fire for views on 1930s famine

Published: 19 December, 2009, 10:09
Edited: 21 January, 2010, 18:13

(16.1Mb) embed video

TAGS: Ukraine, Human rights, History


A Ukrainian political analyst is under scrutiny by security services due to his views on the 1930s USSR famine, the Holodomor, which differs from the authorities’ stance that it was genocide against the Ukrainian people.

After dozens of articles, political analyst Viktor Pirozhenko could be best described as the hard man of modern-day Ukraine – and his strident opinions have caused mixed reactions.

“I criticize the country’s current leadership for policies which are openly ethnically discriminatory and which favor ethnic Ukrainians. I criticize them for reviving neo-Nazism in the country and falsifying history. And, of course, I bring facts to support my point of view,” political analyst Viktor Pirozhenko says.

In one of his articles, Pirozhenko focused on disputed cases of the disastrous 1930s famine in Ukraine. Kiev accuses the Soviet leadership of deliberate genocide directed against Ukrainians.

Many historians – in and beyond Ukraine – stress that the tragedy affected the whole of the USSR.

Pirozhenko says Kiev’s spin is aimed at turning modern-day Ukraine against Russia.

Now the Ukrainian Security Service has got into the act, claiming such views are against the law.

The SBU turned to the state commission on ethics and morality to determine whether that was so.

Just days after the security probe began into Viktor Pirozhenko’s articles, the commission came out with a ruling saying articles which described “the New Ukrainian history as an operation on changing national consciousness” were against the law, and even posed a threat to national security.

President Yushchenko had proposed prosecuting those who deny the 1930’s famine was genocide against Ukrainians. But that never became law. So Pirozhenko does not quite understand what he has done wrong.

“This commission for ethics and morality monitors the media to prevent popularization of violence and pornography. I have no idea what my articles have to do with that. Moreover, I don’t understand which laws I have violated, as my works are purely theoretical. They are historical analysis based on facts and have no calls for violence, separatism or revolution,” Viktor Pirozhenko says.

Vladimir Kornilov heads the Kiev-based CIS countries institution. He says his center has also been a target of the security services.

“The Head of the SBU once said that our center needed to be closed. This happened after we held a conference in Kiev on the 1930s famine. The paradox is that President Yushchenko called for thorough discussions of this issue, and then they wanted to punish us for the conference,” says Vladimir Kornilov, analyst from the CIS Countries Institution.

But Kornilov says the case of Viktor Pirozhenko is nevertheless a mystery to him.

“I know Pirozhenko’s articles very well. And I wouldn’t say that he is radical in his beliefs. Many of us write about these issues. And Pirozhenko – on the contrary – has been very balanced in his works. There are many writers who aren’t as balanced,” Vladimir Kornilov says.

There’s no legal action pending against Pirozhenko. But the incident has got other Ukrainian historians and analysts thinking they could be the next to come under scrutiny.

+8 (11 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Border guards on the Georgian-South Ossetian border (RIA Novosti Photo) 19.12.2009, 09:42

Russian soldiers head to South Ossetia to protect republic’s border

Many South Ossetian refugees have returned to their homes since Russia started to protect the republic’s borders. Russian soldiers headed to the frontier under a deal agreed in April. Residents already feel more secure.

(image from www.vesti.ru) 19.12.2009, 12:37

Two top officials killed in car crash in Russia’s south

Two high-ranking officials of Russia's republics of North Ossetia and Ingushetia have died and one person has been injured in a car crash in the south of the country.

Sarah December 20, 2009, 16:20
0

Andy Dyer In fact, the policy you mentioned is has now become the norm not only in Europe but in North America as well even as Europe is spearheads for the falsification of the events in WWII – such as the EU/US attempt to equate the heroic reeds of the Red Army who liberated Europe from fascism to the actions of the troops and the leadership of the Third Reich. Europe is in a state of moral and intellectual chaos at the moment.

MEJanssen December 20, 2009, 14:25
0

@ johnx, agreed. I saw a map of the 1930s famine and drought areas, and it was a wide swath of territory across Kazakhstan and into northern China. I've never heard how many people died in China but I'm sure it was a significant amount. It was horrible in Ukraine and Kazakhstan, and the bureaucracy made it a thousand times worse, but I don't think it was genocide.

Andy Dyer December 19, 2009, 14:55
0

Parts of Europe have made a very bad mistake criminalising Holocaust Denial at the behest of the Israel Lobby. No matter how dangerous the people publishing those ideas, banning the discussions played into the hands of other bullies playing the victim.