Russian court finds no extremism in Hindu holy book
Published: 28 December, 2011, 08:02
Edited: 28 December, 2011, 17:34
Indian activists of the right-wing Hindu organisation Shiv Sena shout-slogans as they burns a Russian flag during a protest against Russia in Amritsar on December 26, 2011 (AFP Photo / NARINDER NANU)
(15.3Mb) embed videoTAGS: Conflict, Religion, Scandal, Russia, Human rights, Law, India, Natalia Novikova
A Russian court has declared a Hindu holy book not to be extremist, denying prosecutors who sought to ban the text, claiming it incites religious hatred and enmity.
On Wednesday a court in Tomsk, Siberia, held a final hearing on the controversial book “The Bhagavad Gita as It Is” and decided against banning the book.
After the verdict was announced, the prosecutor left the courtroom without commenting on the decision. The defense representative said that the verdict “shows that Russia is really becoming a democratic society.”
The case was initiated by the prosecutor of Tomsk in June. In the petition to the court the prosecutors’ office asserted that the commentaries written by A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, incite religious hatred and enmity. Thus he asked the court to ban the book as extremist.
In August the court held two preliminary hearings, during which the prosecution explained that the commentaries in the book mark anyone, who does not follow Bhagavad Gita as inferior and justify their murder.
The defense, represented by the local chapter of the Krishna Consciousness Organization, applied to the court asking for a human rights ombudsman to be present at the hearings. The court postponed the hearings till December.
Ahead of the final court hearing, India’s external affairs minister S M Krishna met with Russian ambassador Aleksandr Kadakin to express his concerns over the sensitive issue.
Another high profile Indian official, the Indian ambassador to Russia, Ajai Malhotra, has also commented on the issue saying that “the Bhagavad Gita is perhaps the most important and respected scripture in the world,” and has called the procedures in Tomsk “absurd” and “bordering on the bizarre.”
Last week scores of Indian right-wing activists burnt the Russian flag in New Delhi in protest against a possible ban of the Gita. Activists from the Hindu political party, Rashtrawadi Sena, were carrying placards and shouting slogans saying they would not tolerate such disrespect to the Bhagavad Gita. Russian Hindus were also outraged by the trial and have been actively covering the hearings on blogs and on YouTube to attract public attention.
However, Russian authorities rejected the complaints. “This is not about the book itself but about a poor translation and the preface written by the author," said Russian Foreign Ministry spokesman Aleksandr Lukashevich.
‘A broad interpretation of extremism’
“The Bhagavad Gita” has had multiple editions and translations into Russian. The one that led to the trial is supplemented by the commentaries from Prabhupada written in 1968.
Sergey Serebryanny, the head of the Institute of High Humanitarian Studies at the Russian State University of Humanities and a prominent Indologist, says that Prabhupada added a lot of his own ideas and beliefs in his version of “The Bhagavad Gita.”
Regarding the accusations of extremism, Serebryanny explained that Russian authorities interpret the term “extremism” broadly, so they can label extremist anything going against the authorities, whether secular or religious.
“I know some Russian followers of Prabhupada sometimes argue with them, but I think they have the same right for the freedom of conscience as believers of other religious confessions that observe the laws of the Russian Federation,” Serebryanny concluded.
Meanwhile, the Tomsk chapter of Krishna Consciousness said this particular edition of the book had been approved by prosecutors twice in 2004 and 2005. The version on trial, they said, which was published in 2007, had only minor stylistic corrections.
28.12.2011, 07:06
18 comments
North Korea bids farewell to Kim Jong-il (VIDEO, PHOTOS)North Korea held the first day of funeral ceremonies for its late leader Kim Jong-il, who died on December 17, leaving a great deal of uncertainty over the future of the communist state. |
RT’s 10 that shaped 2011: Europe's debt debacleWith 2012 just around the corner, RT continues its own countdown with ten special reports on events that have shaped 2011. We are looking back at major stories through the eyes of RT correspondents who witnessed them. RT's top 10 of 2011 |
Russian, they can't understand the power of Gita. Firstly, they dont know to read the actual script of Gita, it is one of the most peaceful and visdomic version in the holly book among the entire holly books. There are no amendment in the original version, people who can't understand anything they make different version for their own benifits, like the bible has so many versions, whoever read and understand bible has made another additions with an additional stories. Please for god sake stop this none-sense. Due to non-belivers in Russia, almost 80-90% of Russian ladies are doing prostitute business, and that is because of the punishment given by god for not beliving in him and doing such things. Belive in God. and stop doing such things.
My best wishes to you all.







There are many Russians who are very well versed with the Hindu ways and read and write Hindi as true scholars. Even Indians are a tolerant people and have a deep understanding of many religions since the country has people from so many faiths co-existing.
This controversy was actually a waste of time and did not deserve the attention it got. The Bible, Gita, Kuran etc. are revered books and well known across people of all faiths. The courts have thrown the case out and that is where this issue should rest.