Discrimination blamed for Germany’s “failed” multiculturalism
Published: 26 October, 2010, 08:59
Edited: 27 October, 2010, 14:08
TAGS: EU, Immigration
Immigrants in Germany accused of failing to integrate into society say all their efforts to do so are thwarted by discrimination.
The message German society sends to new immigrants is clear: learn the language of Goethe and accept our values, or you do not have a place here.
That was the tough talk from German Chancellor Angela Merkel, who in a controversial speech recently branded multiculturalism a failure, opening up a flood of debate on an extremely sensitive issue.
Immigration, which has for many years in Europe been considered a taboo topic, has suddenly exploded onto the public stage.
Immigration officer Arnold Mengelkoch takes RT to New Koln, in the west of Berlin. “They call this area the Gaza strip because the further along it you go the more Arabic it becomes,” he explains.
With high immigration over the past few decades, Germany has seen the development of mono-cultural communities such as New Koln.
The foreign influence there is obvious. Foreign signs and foreign shop fronts abound. Add to this the discussion of education failures, welfare abuses and crime among immigrant groups and one is handed some very tangible issues that tap into the deep insecurities that many people still hold about immigration.
A recent survey conducted by the Freidrich Ebert Foundation in Germany found that almost a third of respondents felt that immigrants were coming to exploit the country’s welfare system and should be sent home when jobs are scarce. Almost the same number felt that the country was being overrun by foreigners.
“You can see this poster here is a good example,” Arnold Mengelkoch says pointing to a multi-language building plaque. “You have German, English, Turkish [languages]. Everybody can read that. But if it is only in Arabic or only in Turkish, people think: ‘Where do I live? Is this an Arabic city?’”
Much of the ensuing debate has focused on Muslim immigrants, with some migrant families reluctant to integrate into a society they feel is prejudiced against them.
“I don’t think that changing my personality, or the way I look, or the way I talk, or even my mother tongue would have any effect on the German culture,” said immigrant Anissa Feras.
Projects like this local community centre are aimed at aiding integration and teaching children the German language from an early age. But with few bilingual Arabic or Turkish schools, families like Anissa's are sending their children to private schools where her children do not yet learn German.
“To be honest, if there were a German school which would respect [my child’s] religion, I wouldn’t mind her going to that school,” Anissa said.
Despite the tough rhetoric from the top, Germany acknowledges that immigration is desirable for its economy, given that the immigrants are willing to integrate.
“We in industrial countries need the people to come in – every country needs that,” Mr. Mengelkoch said.
Asked if he thinks there has been a rise in anti-immigrant sentiment, Mr. Mengelkoch agrees and says it stems from the subject of religion.
“The people are not used to Islam, Islamic traditions, Islamic clothing and scarf. They are not used to that, and they have to become used to that.”
The great German writer, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, said that no one would talk much in society if they knew how often they misunderstood others. The main challenge now with the debate blown wide-open is to try and bridge cultural divides which have been simmering quietly for a long time. And with such strong statements from top German figures and seemingly wide public support, the message is now loud and clear: taboo or not, the issue of immigration can no longer be shied away from.
Church rehabilitation center brings former convicts back to lifeAn ex-convict pastor has opened Russia's first church-based rehabilitation center for former criminals. The halfway house offers offenders a home and support - in return for hard work and abstaining from vices. |
26.10.2010, 09:40
2 comments
Indian newly-weds offered 'no baby' bonusIndia’s government is offering money to couples who delay childbearing, in an attempt to put a lid on the country’s surging population. But for such a family-oriented nation it is a sensitive issue. |
PR101, yes, given Germany’s Nazi era history, one cannot be totally sure that underlying feelings of ethnic superiority and all that this may potentially imply to foreigners in Germany has been exorcised. No one can ever be absolutely sure of anything in regard to predicting human behaviour anywhere. However, Germany has a pretty impressive track record of cleansing itself of the stain of Nazism, of educating its people about Nazi crimes, of commemorating Nazi victims and of bringing perpetrators of Nazi crimes against humanity to answer for their actions in courts of law. This gives much confidence to the world at large, including those have been victims of Nazism, that Germany has changed. All these pointers are spectacularly absent in Russia. Russia has never faced the reality of its Soviet past, it continues to embrace some of Stalin’s most offensive lies as official Kremlin positions, with one or two exceptions (mostly the result of non-government initiatives) Russia does not commemorate the victims of the Soviet state, it has not apologised to many neighbouring countries that Russians savaged in the service of the Soviet state, and it has brought not even one, single, solitary person who committed crimes against humanity under the Soviet flag to answer for their actions in court. It has not even investigated any. Not surprisingly, hate crimes and manifestations of xenophobia proliferate in Russia in an abundance which is not replicated in Germany.
Sophie wrote: “It says it in the article - there are initiatives such as community centres and schools aimed at teaching children from a young age the language but there are NO bilingual schools for Arabic and Turkish people.” The article says no such thing, Sophie. Rather, it says, “But with few bilingual Arabic or Turkish schools, families like Anissa's are sending their children to private schools where her children do not yet learn German.” While I readily admit I’m not an expert in German education, I can read, and so can you. We both know that “few” does not mean “NO”. Also, that statement seems to apply to state schools, because it is immediately contrasted with an immigrant saying that immigrant families take children to private schools where teaching is not only in their homeland languages, but where no German is taught at all! In other words, private schools which many immigrant children attend are apparently are not even bi-lingual and German is not taught at all. In my view this is both an insult to the country where the immigrants have chosen to live and also a gross disservice to the children themselves, hindering their assimilation into the community. Later they and their families will blame the community because they are not assimilated. I am an Estonian refugee to an English-speaking country. When I started at the local state school, I could not speak a word of English. But I soon learned, and I attended an Estonian Saturday school to learn my own culture. I did not feel the least bit discriminated against by the community, nor did I feel insulted that the community expected me to fit in with it rather than it having to fit in with me. I am seriously unimpressed by immigrants either to Germany or to anywhere else who think that they and their culture ought to be the centre of the universe, and who seriously expect the host country to think the same.












I'm just wondering whatever happened to "when in Rome do as Romans do". Besides, if any community feels like it needs to protect its legacy and culture it should take the responsibility and build its own schools and cultural centers instead of waiting for the host country to do something. Look at the US. Do you have any idea how many different cultures coexist there??? What if at one point in time all of them decide that their home country language should be part of the educational system??? If the Turks in Germany failed to integrate it is because most of them didn't want to do so in the first place. Oh, and we should be able to criticize whoever and whatever we want no matter what religion or background, because there are no "chosen people" or "infidels", there are only morons and rational people on this planet.