The First Caucasian – Georgian TV attack on Russia?
Published: 06 January, 2010, 06:07
Edited: 23 January, 2010, 00:39
TAGS: Scandal, Georgia, Russia, Saakashvili, Mass media
Georgian public broadcasting has launched one of its most ambitious projects. The new TV channel claims to give an alternative perspective on world events. But many experts see it as an anti-Russian info campaign.
The First Caucasian TV channel is broadcasting news in the Russian language, but from a Georgian perspective.
Giya Chanturia, general director of Georgian Public Broadcasting, says that there are many things to talk about for the new channel.
“There are many controversial questions we want to address in Georgia, as well as all over the post-Soviet space,” Chanturia said. “We believe people have the right to hear the truth straight from us about Georgia.”
Producers say there was a dire need for a Russian-language channel in the Caucasus.
Zurab Dvalia, general producer at First Caucasian, claims that Russian remains the main language for a great number of people.
“We all came out from the Soviet Union, so we want to tell the truth in this language,” Dvalia told RT.
But it’s the truth with a Georgian twist. Ahead of its launch, First Caucasian made assurances that they will not feature any propaganda, just news about Georgia. But the very first broadcast made it clear that its rhetoric is not much different from that of the Georgian government, except that now it is being voiced in the Russian language.
The channel has already compared Russian President Medvedev to Vladimir Lenin when it comes to choosing a political course, blatantly accused Moscow of preparing for a war with Ukraine over the Crimean peninsula, and featured extensive clips of an interview with President Mikhail Saakashvili saying Russia lacks democratic culture, which his country has already achieved – all within the first half hour of its broadcast.
Former Georgian Ambassador to Russia Erosi Kitsmarishvili says he will avoid watching First Caucasian at all costs. He himself runs an opposition TV channel, and knows the power the media wields firsthand.
“It would’ve been a good idea for the Caucasus region, if it weren’t another propaganda outlet for the Georgian government to voice its viewpoint,” Kitsmarishvili said. “It will not make relations between Russia and Georgia better – quite the contrary, it has a good chance of complicating them further.”
First Caucasian topped off its New Year’s broadcast with an astrological forecast. Bleak predictions of an impending unrest in the Caucuses, ethnic and political conflicts – the future of Russia-Georgia relations look anything but rosy, according to the channel. And while the channel’s management continues to stress that they are focusing on facts, so far there is very little evidence the channel will say anything that hasn’t already been heard from Saakashvili’s government.
Feliks Stanevsky, Russian ambassador to Georgia from 1996 to 2000, also said that it is a clear and blatant attempt to erode the friendship that has grown through the centuries between the Russian and Georgian people.
“It's out-and-out propaganda, no doubt about that,” Stanevsky said. “It's going to be an anti-Russian TV station. The channel's target audience is Russian speakers in Georgia, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Abkhazia, South Ossetia and I do not rule out the possibility it might also be broadcast in southern Russia. I am sure the channel will aim to turn all possible countries against Russia, above all the West and… Ukraine.”
Freezing temperatures and snowfalls grip EuropeHeavy snowfall and plummeting temperatures are gripping Europe, with three bodies pulled from a Swiss avalanche, raising to seven the death toll in the country's worst avalanche disaster in more than a decade. |
Suicide bomber attacks Russian policeA suicide bomber has killed at least 5 policemen and injured 24 people, including 18 policemen, in an attack on a traffic police station in the southern Russian Republic of Dagestan on Wednesday. |
Nothing wrong with media competition. However, if the Georgian TV channel turns into a nest of blatantly vile anti-Russian propaganda, then this opens up a new headaches for the Georgians. I am not sure what the Georgians hope to gain by these broadcasts since the Abxhazians and Ossetians will never be convinced to return back into the arms of Mother Georgia. Perhaps the purpose is to irritate the Russians Of course, the CIA could use the broadcasts to agitate unrest in the Russian Federation. Then, the Russians can utilize the precedent established by America when it attacked the Serb TV station killing numerous young staffers - their only crime being that they were broadcasting patriotic music to keep up the spirits of the Serb people as America dropped bombs on the defenseless Serb people. If the Georgian station's purpose is to spread anti-Russian propaganda, a few cruise missiles will shut them down. Then of course, those two old drooling grandpas, McCain and Lugar, will be running around the Senate hallways screaming "we are all Georgians today".
I can already see a real danger that Russia will fall into a trap of media lies and deceit. First, this channel has lot of money and lot of PR and the target is Russia! Take that as a given. Second, one must keep in mind that Russia cannot respond this in piecemeal fashion. Russia needs its own media strategy and must offer alterative views to the same targeted audience. Russia was caught flatfooted in the media wars during the Ossetia/Abkhazia/Georgia war. Russia must learn the lesson of that media war. Also Russia must avoid responding reactively. Medvedev wasted, in my, his first year in office by trying to show to the Western media that he is not like Vladimir Putin- it will be shame if he must now show that he is not like Vladimir Lenin!












Oh the irony! How on earth did the reporter kept a straight face when saying this?! 'The first Caucasian news channel said it would not feature any propaganda, just news from Georgia... but its rhetoric is hardly different from that of the Georgian government.'