&host=www.rt.com&uri=/news/euthanasia-switzerland-suicide-contraversy/&via=1.1 4.27.12.137:80 (Footprint 4.8/FPMCP)&ua=CCBot/1.0 (+http://www.commoncrawl.org/bot.html))
Swiss politicians ponder ban on assisted suicide
Published: 12 January, 2010, 08:27
Edited: 13 January, 2010, 05:43
TAGS: Health, Europe, Law, Lifestyle
Recent proposals to restrict or even ban the practice of euthanasia have emerged in Switzerland, where doctors have been permitted to offer the option not only to Swiss residents but also foreigners.
The number of people coming to Switzerland to seek help in ending their life has been steadily rising. Plans to revise the law on assisted suicide stem from the government’s fears that Switzerland may become a “suicide Mecca.” In the meantime, campaigners are worried that changes to the law could deprive people of their last chance to die with dignity.
Dignitas – a Swiss group that helps people die assisted by doctors and nurses – maintains that everyone has the right to choose when to die. Although the group rarely speaks to journalists, the doors of the organization have been open the terminally ill for more than 10 years.
However, critics say what Dignitas is carrying out is “a murky business.”
“EXIT (a group similar to Dignitas) and Dignitas are very commercial,” says Ruedi Aeschbacher of the Evangelical People's Party of Switzerland. “They say they are non-profit, but they make money. And nobody can control them. Nobody can check their books.”
Swiss law punishes those practicing euthanasia only if the person performing the service is pursuing selfish interests.
Dignitas has already helped nearly a thousand foreigners end their lives. Among them a 23-year old rugby player, Daniel James, who was paralyzed after an accident, and British conductor Edward Downes, who was going blind.
Last year the organization even tried to assist in the suicide of a healthy Canadian woman, who wished to die on the same day as her husband.
Bernhard Sutter, a spokesperson for EXIT, says more than half of those who seek the group’s help are not terminally ill. However, EXIT has a detailed review process and a policy not to assist people seeking to end their life due to emotional factors and depression.
Aeschbacher, a Swiss lawmaker, says that when the legislation on euthanasia was first conceived 70 years ago, it did not foresee special clinics helping people die. He says that it is therefore in need of an update.
“It terrifies me that Switzerland could make those changes,” says Debby Purdy, who lives in the UK and suffers from multiple sclerosis.
Purdy is not packing her bags for Switzerland, but says she wants to have the option to do so if her pain becomes unbearable.
In Britain anyone helping Purdy to end her life could be sentenced to up to 14 years in prison.
“It’s not that I think it should be an easy option, but I think if people suffer unbearably, only the person who's suffering can decide whether it is bearable or unbearable – doctors can't tell you that your pain is being managed fine. If you're in pain, you're in pain,” Purdy says.
Thus, before the issue of assisted suicide makes it to the inevitable referendum, the Swiss government and the public have a few important questions to answer.
12.01.2010, 08:22
5 comments
Close-knit family with just 28 adoptive childrenA Russian couple could not become biological parents – but with 28 adoptive kids they do feel happy. And, more importantly, the children feel loved and cared for. |
12.01.2010, 10:54
3 comments
Russians’ recipe for losing pounds: take a puffAs obesity-fighting tricks go, one is particularly popular in Russia. More often than anywhere in the world, Russians try to keep off unwanted calories by trading an extra snack for an extra cig, a recent poll revealed. |
Well, it seems complicated. Purdy has the option of jumping off of a bridge if so she choses. That option is up to her. People who are going for assisted suicide must feel pressure from somewhere, perhaps in finances and from their struggling families unless they are a vegetable staring off into space. They need help and people are content that they went out of this life nicely. How convenient for everyone. Death is death. Honestly, vegetables need a good friend. A comfortable death goes against the discussion of suicide for the aware which seems to be more about destruction and the release from pain and circumstance than actually dying. Unless you find a high cliff to jump off of, and even that might fail you, trust, you'll fight the moment of death no matter and perhaps that's what stops so many and leaves others with several failed attempts. Suicide is quite a private thing. It's been exploited and now people are banking off of it and using it in several cultures out of ordinary context. It should be an instinctive reaction and private.