VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Ash, swine flu and other causes of mass hysteria – how real is the danger?  
MORE ON THE STORY
19.04.2010, 20:46

Icelandic eruption has price tag for airlines

The eruption of Iceland’s Eyjafjallajoekull volcano has a mounting economic price tag with airlines bearing the brunt and thousands of passengers stranded.

19.04.2010, 17:07 3 comments

Mother Nature gives Globalized Man a volcanic spanking

Once upon a time, people were tossed into the mouths of active volcanoes in order to appease the wrath of the gods. Today, we throw scientists at volcanoes in order to appease the wrath of the people.

Photograph courtesy Árni Sæberg, Icelandic Coast Guard 16.04.2010, 15:21 2 comments

Icelandic volcano affects air traffic across Europe

European air traffic have been crippled for several days now as the colossal cloud of Icelandic volcanic ash continues to blow slowly across Northern Europe.

25.10.2010, 16:31 14 comments

Vatican rejects “chosen people” claim, calls on Israel to end “occupation”

A high-ranking Israeli official on Sunday slammed a statement from Catholic bishops, who called for international organizations to lead the cause of Palestinian statehood.

RIA Novosti  / Vitaliy Ankov 14.09.2010, 06:37 1 comment

Russian police: to be given new disguise or actual reform?

Russia is preparing an overhaul of its police following several massive scandals that shook the force. The new draft law has been published online and has prompted large-scale feedback from experts and the public.

01.07.2010, 08:43 6 comments

Holocaust crimes equated to Communists’ actions

Hungary has passed a new law equating Communist era crimes to those of the Holocaust.

Video footage from US Apache helicopter showing the murder 06.04.2010, 05:52 16 comments

WikiLeaks shows reporter killings in Iraq

WikiLeaks has released a video taken from a US Apache helicopter showing the murder of two Reuters journalists in Iraq in 2007. Will there be any repercussions for the US?

22.05.2009, 00:59 12 comments

Rotting from the inside: sex abuse and the Catholic Church

Catholic sex abuse has a long and ongoing history intertwined with that of religious institutions.

Image from 3.bp.blogspot.com 08.10.2010, 06:32 6 comments

Building of mosques in Poland – sign of Islamisation or tribute to human rights?

Activists say the construction of a second mosque in Warsaw is part of the Islamisation of the country and could eventually lead to radicalism and terrorism.

09.07.2010, 07:53 2 comments

Canned CNN reporter becomes the news after controversial tweet

Octavia Nasr, a 20-year veteran for CNN International, is the latest victim to be fired and publicly dismissed for careless use of microblogging website Twitter.

Ash, swine flu and other causes of mass hysteria – how real is the danger?

Published: 20 April, 2010, 07:55
Edited: 21 April, 2010, 20:14

(13.1Mb) embed video

TAGS: Natural disasters, Scandal, Europe, Human rights, Mass media, Psychology, Vehicles


Volcanic ash has left hundreds of thousands trapped in airports, paralyzing flight connections in Europe. As the airspace starts to reopen, some are wondering if the response to the ash cloud was an overreaction.

Many flights still remain cancelled. According to meteorologists, the skies over Europe are beginning to clear as the volcano ash cloud is pushed away from European airspace.

The situation for the UK still looks gloomy, as recent weather reports suggest the ash cloud is returning to British air space.

Airlines are cursing European regulators for red tape and bad risk assessment.

Travelers, left stranded all around the globe, wonder if it was more about hazard or hype.

Arkady Tishkov, from the Institute of Geography at the Russian Academy of Sciences, believes the ash panic was baseless.

"The overall hysteria surrounding this volcano eruption is totally unwarranted,” Tishkov said. “This is not the largest volcano and often the plumes sent into the atmosphere reach even greater heights. The scale of this eruption is not that great. What we are witnessing now is an unnecessary apocalyptic reaction. But there are no grounds for it."


Click to enlarge

Grounds or no grounds, among the first things people heard about the ash cloud was that it could cause problems with teeth and bones, it is extremely dangerous for those with asthma and, of course, it could crash their planes. Only later did reports come that it is not that bad after all. However, the effect was already there. Many dubbed it another episode of hysteria in the 21st Century.

It took a year to realize that the outbreak of swine flu was not really an outbreak, and that normal, everyday seasonal flu kills many more people. Back in June last year, though, a mask seemed to be a must-have.

Drug firms cashed in on the panic, and the World Health Organization stands accused of announcing “a false pandemic”.

But psychologists say it is not about scientists' wrongdoings.

"People believe TV, that's the problem,” said Sergey Klyuchnikov, a psychologist. “Any event, when shared by the media, gets exaggerated by millions of times. Especially when it has to do with people's health and safety. Panic is contagious; people can't receive negative information and just keep it to themselves."

Now, when information is just a click away, spreading fear and capitalizing on fear has become much easier.

The impact of bird flu on humans has been assessed as very limited, but back in 2003, many thought it was going to claim millions of lives.

And at the beginning of the millennium, one part of the world sincerely expected everything from your clock radio to the Internet to nuclear power stations simply to stop working when all those zeros came in.

Unresolved apocalyptic scenarios are still lingering, one of them is global warming.

"We're being told there is an international scientific consensus on global warming,” said Konstantin Simonov, the head of National energy security fund. “But that's not true! We don't have enough evidence. And what’s more, we can't say that it's the carbon dioxide that could be causing the warming. But we are supposed to actually to take the two statements as a fact."

Psychologists say that people today are more exposed to mass hysteria, but they are also developing an emotional and psychological immunity. There are fears that people's reactions could become too numb to respond to any real danger.

The fear of perishing in a cloud of volcano dust is fading and now reasonable doubt arises as to whether or not paralyzing almost all air traffic in Europe for nearly a week was the right decision.

American radio host Michael Rivero believes the recent global warming scandal made British meteorologists overreact in a bid to try to regain the public's trust.

“A lot of people are thinking that the British meteorological office…in efforts to trying redeem itself in terms of usefulness to the public, may have in fact overreacted and over-emphasized the dangers of the volcanic cloud coming out of Iceland and declared a very wide-ranging no-fly zone that was inappropriate,” Rivero told RT. “On the other hand, you can’t be too careful with volcanic ash. Obviously, on the side of airlines and the travel industry as a whole – hotels and everything – money is very much on the line, there is a constant flow of tourism, and if it’s not happening, if travel is not happening, money is being lost and most of Europe is already in severe financial stress, much as the United States is right now.”

Watch full video with Michael Rivero

downloadembed

Frank Furedi, professor of sociology at the University of Kent, Britain, says that shutting down the airspace was an over-reaction based on speculation rather than scientific evidence.

“It’s very sad that in many respects the EU…finds it very difficult to do the most basic planning when it comes to such a major issue. I do think it’s important to realize that many countries all over the world face volcanic eruption. For example, countries like Italy still manage to have air traffic just by taking sensible precautions,” says Frank Furedi.

Watch full video with Frank Furedi

downloadembed

+7 (12 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Landing in Normandy on D-Day 20.04.2010, 05:01 3 comments

“If a pal next to you falls – it’s none of your business” WWII veteran remembers

RT presents “War Witness,” a special project dedicated to the 65th anniversary of victory in World War II.

RIA Novosti / Shimanskiy, STF 20.04.2010, 11:12 1 comment

One boy tells me,"Ma'am, don’t sit down, please. You'll freeze to death!"

RT presents War Witness – a special project dedicated to the 65th anniversary of the Victory in the Second World War.

Epsilon April 21, 2010, 00:45
0

Worst thing is that the lockdown of airspace started in Norway:/ (where I live). Then the other countries followed... I'm sure that it is no problem for the planes to fly, and if it is the can just fly under the ash (or over it). This is all actually based on computer calculations in Britain, and not actuall tests and samples of the air...:O

Sam April 20, 2010, 20:29
0

All this hysteria is based on one incident that happened in 1982 when BA flight 9 flow directly into a cloud of volcanic ash from mount galunggung in indonesia. That was 28 years ago and there was no other recorded event as far as i know. Since then the engines are more powerful and no one is planing on flying directly into the cloud. I was meant to travel out of Manchester airport this morning. what gets me is the total lack of support for the passengers.The whole of yesterday was on the phone trying to find out if my flight will go after the planned reopening of Manchester airport after 9am. The certain dutch air company has an automated message on all its line saying they cant help me with anything and referring me to their web page that does not work. the travel agent I used has disconnected their phones and the airport keeps moving their time to reopen with no regards to the passengers that have to make their way there just to find out its closed again. People are stuck all across the world in poor conditions and some have to pay large amounts to get back by road and sea. In the long run the air companies will get cash compensations from their respective governments, but how about the people? I am lucky since all it has cost me is my time and phone bill.

Richard April 20, 2010, 09:51
0

Some years ago, a 747 Jumbo jet was flown into a volcanic cloud - NOT DUST PARTICLES. The cloud was, as you can imagine, dense. As a result the four engines shut down. The plane headed earthwards. It was just before the plane was hit earth that the pilot was able to restart the engines. It is understood that based on this the decision was made to ground everyone. The comment about bad risk assessment, in my opinion, is quite correct. I am a safety advisor and one of tasks is to risk assess. It is not an exact science. The decisions taken are, of course, over reaction, as with many other instances. I have seen it and experienced the over reaction by others. There is no common sense approach any more and as such many people are left out of pocket because of stupid individuals who thick that they can control the universe by saying they are Safety Advisors and as such the world sits on their decision. Pathetic little people. These decisions have damaged my reputation and now, makes my life very difficult. Classic example, in england, of this stupidity, was when company and individuals stated that Step Ladders were banned. I ask you. And they blamed the Safety Authoritive body for this when no such thing was said. These people had not followed guidance and it was easier to ban something and blame someone else. It is pathetic and over the top. Anyone want a Safety Advisor who has a common sense approach to situations, I am sure RT will forward you my contact outlining all the necessary details quoting Health and Safety