VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   ‘EU lacks sense of society to politically unite’  
MORE ON THE STORY
European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso (R) and Greek Prime Minister Lucas Papademos (L) (AFP Photo / GEORGES GOBET) 04.01, 19:55 7 comments

Highway to Hell? Greece barrels towards euro exit

Greece could be forced out of the eurozone unless international lenders throw it a second 130-billion-euro lifeline. But while Greek leaders see disaster ahead if they crash out of the monetary union, there very well might be no other option.

Eurozone crisis
Picture of a Parisian shopwindow, 09 January 2002 bearing a Euro logo shaped with sales ads, on the first day of the post-Christmas sales in the French capital. The sales were delayed so consumers could first get used to euro cash before having to deal with up to 4 different prices figures after elbowing their way to bargains. (AFP Photo/Joel Saget) 02.01, 09:48 6 comments

Euro woes: No joy for 10-year-old currency

2012 marks 10 years since Europeans first held euro notes and coins in their hands. But prospects are grim for Europe's single currency in the New Year, as the region's leaders warn of tough sacrifices in this "most severe test in decades".

The European community bids farewell to the worst year for the eurozone, which saw the toughest economic crisis in decades.  (AFP Photo / Louisa Gouliamaki ) 31.12.2011, 20:47 4 comments

The year of dissent: Battling Europe

The European community bids farewell to the worst year for the eurozone, which saw the toughest economic crisis in decades. The battle to save the single currency left boardrooms and flooded European streets - most commonly and violently in Athens.

Eurozone crisis
RT’s 10 that shaped 2011: Europe's debt debacle 28.12.2011, 09:37

RT’s 10 that shaped 2011: Europe's debt debacle

With 2012 just around the corner, RT continues its own countdown with ten special reports on events that have shaped 2011. We are looking back at major stories through the eyes of RT correspondents who witnessed them.

RT's top 10 of 2011
AFP Photo / Attila Kisbenedek 21.12.2011, 16:18 13 comments

‘EU governance system to spread across whole planet’

With the sun setting on US global hegemony, the European model of governance is set to be adopted across the planet in a matter of a century, argues the founder and president of the French Institute of International Relations, Thierry de Montbrial.

Eurozone crisis

‘EU lacks sense of society to politically unite’

Published: 05 January, 2012, 19:05

Communist-affiliated protesters, including many laidoff workers, gather in the center of Athens on December 20, 2011 during a rally to demand immediate measures for the unemployed (AFP Photo / Louisa Gouliamaki)

(96.0Mb) embed video
TRENDS: Eurozone crisis

TAGS: EU, Crisis, Protest, Politics, Europe, Currencies, Employment, Economy


“A monetary union without political union is impossible to maintain,” economist Arjo Klamer said 20 years ago. And as Europe struggles to deal with the euro crisis, the EU countries are still too different to politically unite, Klamer told RT.

Klamer, who is a professor of the Economics of Art and Culture at Erasmus University in Rotterdam, says a political union should be formed now, because stronger fiscal coordination and better social policy would support the euro. However, “There is too much heterogeneity. The countries are too different. Countries are too attached to their own sovereignty,” he told RT.

Klamer says European countries have a hard time working together on international issues. “At the moment it is inconceivable that Britain will give up their rights and also France is not even thinking of giving that up. Germany will be too powerful. There’s simply too much that prevents Europe from becoming a political union.”

However, if you asked German Chancellor Angela Merkel, she would say that a “political union” is already taking shape. According to Klamer, Merkel is basing this statement on plans and suggestions.

“These are suggestions or plans, to have stricter rules. And to enforce those rules, in her view, in her reality, that is moving towards a political union,” he said. “But my critique is, what is lacking, and what is really needed for a political union is also a sense of society.”

Some call for a significant transfer of spending and taxing powers to a central EU government and parliament a “democratic sacrifice.”

“It is an idea that I think in the end will backfire,” argues Klamer. “If you centralized this power too much, then what we will see is a lack of dynamics, a lack of flexibility as we see right now because it takes forever to make these decisions. It takes forever to get it through all these different parliaments. And then it takes even longer to implement it.”

Meanwhile, a Greek government spokesman has said that “Greece faces an exit from the euro bloc unless it clinches a deal on a second 130-billion-euro bailout from its international lenders.”

“They use it now as an argument to enforce all kinds of cutbacks and to get popular consent which they need in order to make the policy effective,” says Klamer. “I think that in Greece there is still an overall desire to hold on to the euro because the Greeks are very suspicious of their governments. So they desperately want to have ‘European government’ involved in their country because that’s sort of a countervailing power against their own politicians.”

However, whether that rhetoric will bring results is another issue altogether. “I think the left, right and center are preparing for the fallout of Greece, that the Greeks are forced to step out of the euro, because this is unsustainable.”

According to Klamer, the best strategy for Greece would be to devalue their own currency, to make their country much cheaper, and use that as the beginning of a new effort to organize commercial activity in conditions which would enable them to sell and export.

The alternative strategy is painful, argues Klamer. It is “lowering salaries and wages and cutting back and that causes a huge depression in that economy.”

The main cheerleaders of the euro are Merkel and Sarkozy, with French and German elections coming up in 2012 and 2013 respectively.

Klamer says holding on to the euro with everyone making sacrifices, forsaking national interests in the name of European ones is “a message that’s very hard to sell in election time.

“But that is also again an illustration of a lack of political union. A lack of society that will become an issue and that the fate of the European Union is dependent upon national elections,” he said. “You cannot imagine the fate of any country is dependent upon the outcome of local elections. That’s unheard of. And that illustrates once again that the union in Europe is not that strong. It’s forced. It exists among the European establishments.”

“So if you walk around Brussels, you feel like the European Union is for real. But as soon as you’re away from Brussels and walk around in the country in the rest of Europe, then you see that Brussels is far away from that and not really the reality that people live with.”

Experts and analysts, even if they consider themselves Eurosceptics, are already saying that sticking with the euro and being “forced” into closer European integration is probably the better option because the alternative is a financial crisis.

However, Klamer supports the idea of leaving the euro behind, even if this brings about a crisis.

“Focus less on economic growth. Focus more on sustainability. But especially focus on quality – quality of food, quality of living conditions, being concerned about local resources. And strong regions. Strong societies. Strong cultures. That is what we are interested in,” he said.

+1 (1 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Image from infokart.ru 05.01, 16:18 12 comments

Space powers propose roadmap for flight to Mars

Despite various economic issues undermining efforts by the world’s leading space powers to forge a program for future manned flights to the Red Planet, an international working group has come up with a universal space exploration roadmap.

HORMUZ: Iranian navy conducts the "Velayat-90" naval wargames in the Strait of Hormuz in southern Iran on January 1, 2012. (AFP Photo/Jamejamon Line/Ebrahim Noroozi) 05.01, 20:23 36 comments

Oil toy: ‘Iran embargo to bring little joy to EU’

EU states have reached an agreement in principle to ban Iran’s oil exports. But with the EU’s staggering economy dependent on Iranian oil, the economic problems crippling the West could increase twofold, says political analyst Christoph R. Hoerstel.

Iran tension
Nay Lin Maung January 06, 2012, 02:08
-1

I [Nay Lin Maung] start to see very clearly about how European Union is going to reform or change it.

 

I [Nay Lin Maung] hope that European Union could accomplish what he wants to do it.

The whole world needs to watch the movie The Wave January 06, 2012, 01:42
+1

and no it's not some Conspiracy movie.  Before political leaders start spouting of Unity like Dimitriev

kris (unregistered) January 05, 2012, 20:58
-1

I will tell you where is the problem. The problem is, that only some countries are brainy.
The rest voted for politicians they want to only steal the national wealth. They are not able to manage their own country. It is almost impossible to bring a government in that countries which will not steal the peoples natural wealth. Mafia
Spain, Italy, Czech, Slovak etc.
I hope EU will survive with Euro, but it will not be easy. Do not forget, that EU with Euro is very young, very young. But strong enough to be the strongest