VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Erroneous famine photos spark foul cries  
MORE ON THE STORY
RIA Novosti / Grigory Susoyev 13.02.2010, 12:09 35 comments

Ukraine-Russia: friends will be friends

Ukraine’s relationship with Russia has been on the rocks in recent years - but that is about to change, according to the incoming Ukrainian president.

14.01.2010, 18:40 22 comments

Yushchenko brings Stalin to court over genocide

Kiev’s Court of Appeals has found Josef Stalin and other Bolshevik leaders guilty of genocide against the Ukrainians during the famine, or “Holodomor” as it is called in Ukraine, of 1932-33.

Ukraine, Kiev: Deputies of Ukraine's parliament fight during a parliament sitting in Kiev on April 27, 2010. (AFP Photo / Sergei Supinskiy) 27.04.2010, 11:55 9 comments

Brawl, smoke bombs and eggs fail to stop Ukrainian MPs

Ukraine’s parliament has ratified a new naval base agreement with Russia despite the opposition’s resistance. The vote was mired with a fistfight, smoke bombs and hooliganism.

Russian Federation, Moscow : Russian President Dmitry Medvedev (L) shakes hands with Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovich (R) at the Kremlin in Moscow on March 5, 2010. (AFP Photo / POOL / Natalia Kolesnikova) 05.03.2010, 16:15 8 comments

End of “bad streak” in Russian-Ukrainian relations - Medvedev

President Dmitry Medvedev said he hopes that with the election of Viktor Yanukovich, the “bad streak” in Russian-Ukrainian relations has finally come to an end.

Dmitry Medvedev 11.08.2009, 20:02 6 comments

“No new Russian ambassador to be sent to Ukraine” - Medvedev

Russia-Ukraine relations are at an extremely low point now, and in the current situation, Moscow has taken the decision to refrain from sending an ambassador to Kiev, said President Medvedev in his new video address.

Russian Federation, Moscow: Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov (R) meets with his Ukrainian counterpart Petro Poroshenko (L) in Moscow on October 23, 2009. (AFP Photo / Natalia Kolesnikova) 23.10.2009, 14:08 5 comments

Ukraine seeks reset in relations with Russia

Ukraine’s Foreign Minister is in Moscow seeking to reset relations after a period of high tension between Moscow and Kiev. The two sides agreed to depoliticize points of conflict.

Vladimir Putin (AFP Photo / RIA Novosti / Pool / Alexey Nikolsky) 01.11.2009, 22:51 5 comments

Ukraine might fail to pay for gas – Putin to EU

Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin has informed his Swedish counterpart of possible Ukrainian problems paying for Russian gas and its transit to European consumers.

05.03.2010, 19:13 2 comments

New era for Russia and Ukraine?

The atmosphere at Friday’s press conference with Medvedev and Yanukovich would have been hard to imagine with the Ukrainian’s predecessor, said RIA Novosti’s Dmitry Babich, but there is still cause for concern.

27.11.2009, 17:12 3 comments

Ukraine changes mind over Russia’s role in Stalin-era famine

Quite unexpectedly, top Ukrainian politicians have started making statements saying that Russia should not be blamed for the famine that claimed millions of lives in Ukraine in 1932-33.

15.06.2009, 17:50 3 comments

Ukraine’s new take on Holodomor: Moscow’s not to blame

The head of Ukraine’s security service has said that Holodomor, the mass famine of the early 1930s, was done by Ukrainian authorities of the time and has nothing to do with today’s Russia.

Erroneous famine photos spark foul cries

Published: 10 March, 2009, 09:31

(11.1Mb) embed video

TAGS: Russia, Ukraine, Politics


In the city of Sevastopol the Ukrainian Security Service opened a photo exhibition on Holodomor, the 1930’s famine in the USSR, but local politicians have noticed that some of the pictures have nothing to do with it.

“We established that some photos were taken from a US photo blog on the Great Depression of 1929-1930s. One of them made in 1935 in Arkansas, shot by Benjamin Shahn. Another one was taken in Oklahoma. Four out of six photos presented at the exhibition have nothing to do with Ukraine,” said city council deputy Andrey Merkulov.

Historians and politicians in Russia and Ukraine are at odds about both the reasons and the death toll of the disastrous famine of the 1930s.

Kiev believes the death toll was up to nine million in Ukraine alone and claims it was genocide against Ukrainians.

Moscow is firm in its view that it was caused by disastrous agricultural policies of the soviet government and the death toll was half of Kiev's estimates.

Quest for national tragedy

After being elected, President Yushchenko went on a massive campaign to have the events recognized as a crime against humanity.

“We recently published 19 books about the famine. We created the first ever name-by-name death toll list. And without Yushchenko this would have never happened,” said Vasiliy Marochko, Ukrainian historian.

Last November these efforts ended in monuments to the famine being erected all over the country.

Some lashed out at the president for what they describe as excessive attention to things in the past, when it’s the present which requires serious attention.

“He spent millions on that. That’s in the times when our doctors, teachers, workers are struggling to make ends meet. It is Yushchenko, who’s orchestrating a modern day famine in Ukraine,” said Leonid Grach, Ukrainian opposition MP.

The scandal in Sevastopol is nothing new. Russian historians previously accused a similar exhibition in Kiev for displaying pictures from Russia rather than from Ukraine. With new details and twists in the famine story emerging every year, it appears the tragedy of the 1930s will be making headlines for years to come.

+8 (16 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
10.03.2009, 08:59 1 comment

North Korea puts troops on alert

North Korea's military is on full combat alert, as the US and South Korea hold joint war games. Pyongyang also says any attempts to intercept the launch of its communications satellite would be considered an act of war.

10.03.2009, 09:55

Eco-groups call for hunt on high profile poachers

Wild life activists in Russia are calling on the government to punish officials who they claim were poaching rare animals in Siberia. The practice only came to light after a helicopter carrying the hunters crashed.