VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Russian weather data cherry picked by UK climatologists – report  
MORE ON THE STORY
29.06.2010, 18:29 19 comments

US “lobby war” behind Russian spy charges

As international special interest groups are vying for influence in the US government, the line between espionage and lobbying work is becoming dangerously vague.

Medvedev-Obama
19.07.2010, 12:55 18 comments

Russia acquires the soft touch

From its reasonable response to the US “spy” case, to accepting responsibility for some unfortunate moments in history, Moscow is showing a fresh new face on the world stage.

Medvedev-Obama
Yury Luzhkov (RIA Novosti / Aleksey Kudenko) 28.09.2010, 14:32 10 comments

President Medvedev sacks Moscow Mayor Luzhkov

The Russian president has signed a decree firing Moscow Mayor Yury Luzhkov, who was in power for almost two decades.

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev (L) stands with European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso (R) and Swedish Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt during a one-day EU-Russia summit in Stockholm November 18, 2009 (AFP Photo / Getty Images) 18.11.2009, 18:34 3 comments

“Russia and EU are inevitable partners” – Medvedev

After the Lisbon Treaty comes in force, Russia-EU relations won’t suffer considerable changes as they are “inevitable and amicable partners,” President Dmitry Medvedev told a media briefing in Stockholm.

12.07.2010, 17:33 9 comments

The spy thriller that wasn’t

The slowly fading US-Russian spy case, which began amidst great hype and promise, has turned out to be so dull that the world is turning to a number of wild theories to explain it.

Medvedev-Obama
30.08.2010, 17:24 3 comments

Russia’s brutal summer inspires green awakening

Blame it on this summer’s deadly heat wave or political brinkmanship, but Russian leaders appear more willing to provide space for green alternatives.

Medvedev-Obama
29.04.2010, 17:35 7 comments

Era of confrontation with Russia over– Ukrainian President

On Thursday Dmitry Medvedev and Viktor Yanukovich signed the bill ratifying the agreement on Russia’s Black Sea fleet in Ukraine.

Greenpeace demonstration in Parliament Square in Copenhagen (AFP Photo / Adrian Dennis) 15.12.2009, 19:00 2 comments

Climate change talks shouldn’t turn into witch hunt – Medvedev

President Medvedev has said that talks on a new climate treaty that are underway in Copenhagen should not lead to a “witch hunt”. He said there has been unfair pressure put on countries rich in hydrocarbons.

RIA Novosti 21.07.2010, 10:17 2 comments

Putin calls for “firmer control” as Russia's deadly drought continues

Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin has placed his First Deputy in charge of monitoring progress against a heat wave and drought that has devastated agriculture in the country.

A Russian man walks through downtown Moscow on December 16, 2009. Temperatures in Russia's capital city have dropped to -22 celsius (-11 fahrenheit) (AFP PHOTO / Natalia Kolesnikova) 17.12.2009, 08:57 5 comments

Copenhagen strives to forge climate change agreement

President Dmitry Medvedev is preparing to join over a hundred leaders at the UN Climate Change Summit in Copenhagen, which was stalled for nine-hours on Wednesday due to wrangles over the text to be used for the talks.

Russian weather data cherry picked by UK climatologists – report

Published: 18 December, 2009, 08:25
Edited: 03 April, 2010, 14:44

Russian weather station

(32.7Mb) embed video

TAGS: Global warming, Scandal, Medvedev, Politics


As skeptics at the Copenhagen summit are demanding proof that climate change is man-made, a Russian think-tank has accused British researchers of manipulating Russian weather data which does not fit into alarmist theory.

World leaders have launched a last-ditch attempt to reach a consensus on the final day of the UN climate summit in Copenhagen. But with much bickering between rich and poor nations during nearly two weeks of talks, many doubt a new deal will be agreed upon.

The rows have been over the amounts of carbon emission cuts and financial aid to help developing countries also make the cuts.

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, who is attending the conference, has addressed delegates on Friday.

Ahead of the trip to Copenhagen, he signed into law the Russian Climate Doctrine, a document outlining the estimated risks of global warming and Russian government’s planned measures to counter them.

It is planned to raise the energy efficiency of the Russian economy by 40 per cent by 2020. And to cut carbon emissions, Russia is going to raise the industrial efficiency of the economy, develop renewable and alternative energies, implement financial and tax policies to cut greenhouse gases, and sensibly approach the use of wood and the creation of sustainable forests.

Meanwhile, a new climate scandal is gaining momentum. The Moscow-based Institute for Economic Analysis (IEA) has accused the Hadley Centre for Climate Prediction and Research of the British Meteorology Office of only using statistics from weather stations in Russia that fitted its theory on global warming, and ignoring those that did not.

The British Met Office’s Hadley Centre and the University of East Anglia’s Climate Research Unit, which was earlier involved in a scandal dubbed “Climategate” by some media, jointly run the climate database.

The Centre has recently made public part of the raw data used by HadCRUT, its joint research team with the Climate Research Unit of the University of East Anglia, in order to diffuse the recent row over leaked emails revealing an alleged conspiracy by climatologists and politicians.

In a report this week, the IEA says the HadCRUT’s study of climate change ignored data from three quarters of the weather stations on the territory of Russia. This includes “more than 40% of the area,” which was not included, not due to missing data, but “for some other reasons.”

That means 40% of Russia’s territory is unrepresented in the world’s most important temperature record.

This cherry-picking and misrepresenting data is nothing new, according to those opposed to the summit in Copenhagen.

“There was the famous Hockey Stick diagram, produced by somebody called Mann, which purported to show that for the last thousand years temperature had been fairly steady, before suddenly going up very rapidly,” says climate skeptic Stuart Wheeler. “But it's now been shown that any separate figures could be manipulated in the way Mann's system did to produce a Hockey Stick diagram.”

Moreover, of the data available for the same location, the British researchers chose incomplete sets of temperature with growth trends over complete ones that did not fit into the global warming model. Also, data from stations located in cities – which are always likely to be warmer due to waste heat generated by local industries and homes – were preferred over those in remote areas, the IEA says.

All in all, the institute evaluates the difference between the growth of average temperatures between 1870s and 1990s, based on all data available for Russia and those delivered by HadCRUT, as at least 0.64 degrees Celsius.

The report goes on to say that if similar practices, which the IEA bluntly calls “overstating the scale of the warming by HadCRUT”, were used in the selection of raw data from other regions of the world, global estimates for climate change should be seriously amended.

HadCRUT figures are being used by climatologists at the COP-15 international climate change conference currently underway in Copenhagen – but the new scandal surrounding climate change science does not seem to have distracted the carbon emissions summit. It is careening towards its closing moments, and the only topic under discussion there is whether or not any kind of meaningful deal will be signed.

But it is looking less and less likely, and some Russian skeptics suggest that is a good thing for the country.

“This scare-story kills two birds with one stone. It makes money and limits Russia's presence on the European market,” says Konstantin Simonov, director of Russia’s National Energy Security Foundation. “The logic's simple: global warming is the main threat facing the world, the main reason for global warming is carbon emission, and the main source of carbon emission is fossil fuels – oil and gas. And Russia is the leading exporter of oil and gas in Europe and in the world,” noted Simonov.

And not signing an agreement could also be a good thing for the rest of the world. Even the International Panel on Climate Change admits that a temperature rise of not more than 3% would increase world food production.

+65 (67 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Images from zpravy.idnes.cz 17.12.2009, 21:38 7 comments

Top Czech commander resigns over Nazi scandal

A top military official from the 480-strong Czech contingent in Afghanistan has resigned following an incident with two Czech soldiers caught wearing Nazi symbols while serving in Afghanistan.

Photo by Sergey Fudinenko 18.12.2009, 12:29 6 comments

Climate scandal: new evidence of dubious research

Russia is becoming a focal point in the battle of ideas over climate change. Russian weather data appears to have been tinkered with by UK climate researchers to overstate the scale of global warming.

Rhoops April 03, 2010, 14:04
0

Peter's comments patronising Bianca for her completely comprehensible and articulate viewpoint, are most revealing: "you seem to think that you understand the situation and that scientists - highly trained, highly intelligent, highly experienced academics who aren't illiterate - are all conspiring to con the world [?]..." Well Peter, these scientists are also HIGHLY PAID, and yes they do therefore have a very clear motive for distorting the data to ensure their viewpoint (and income) are protected. Your notion that scientists are innately objective is the product of the half baked non classical semi educated pseudo intellectualism prevalent amongst the political classes in the UK. This mob also have a very large financial incentive to keep the bureaucratic infrastructure expanding to increase the number of worthless upper middle class high paid jobs they monopolise. If as you say scientists are so right, would you care to explain what happened to all the 'logical' ideas since Aristotle began systematic analysis in 'The Athenian Constitution' and where is that systematic analysis now? And the Aristotelian World view, and the Renaissance world view that surplanted it? Knowledge is not absolute, your scientists are not absolutely right, they and their predecessors never have been. They are as biased as everybody is, but to those with a limited intellectual horizon, this is not always obvious.

Peter December 29, 2009, 14:43
0

December 19, 2009, 08:08, Wig wrote > I would not believe a word the UK says about climate change or anything else. They seem to think that because they were once an empire, ill-gotten, that there is no-one smarter than them. Nonsense!! Expletive, expletive, expletive!!! Thank you for that intelligent comment. The Russian Empire is also dead, Brits just don't all get blind drunk on Vodka but are still capable of logical thinking.

Peter December 29, 2009, 14:40
0

There is no 'EastEngland group' whatever that might be, it's the University of East Anglia, and there is no email, there were thousands of them, the vast majority innocuous;a few were cherry picked out of context and implications made of their meaning. ALL of them have been explained as perfectly understandable in light of the scientists being constantly harrassed by idiots without a scrap of scientific training or understanding. Bianca, I assumed from your appalling English that you too were Russian, but from 'here in Washington DC' you appear to be American!. You seem to think that you understand the situation and that scientists - highly trained, highly intelligent, highly experienced academics who aren't illiterate - are all conspiring to con the world. Deepfire, when have you published a peer reviewed paper on this subject?