VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД RSS
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Russian carrier becomes “Made in China” vessel prototype?   Comments  
MORE ON THE STORY
SAU MSTA, Russia 09.02.2010, 18:58 24 comments

Copycat weapons a threat to Russia's economic security

Pirate production is among the key problems of the global weapons market. Superpowers that used to help their allies establish their own defense industries during the Cold War now face the consequences of that help.

15.02.2010, 15:28 7 comments

Russia and India to ink atomic deal

Moscow and New Delhi will sign an agreement next month on civilian nuclear power cooperation, said Russian Deputy Prime Minister Sergey Sobyanin, who is on official visit to India.

07.10.2010, 23:57 5 comments

Bulava missile: 13th time lucky

The newest Russian intercontinental nuclear missile Bulava has successfully been tested on Thursday. All warheads hit their targets on Kamchatka Peninsula.

A parade marking the end of Russia-China military exercises. August 2007, (AFP Photo / Maxim Marmur) 28.04.2009, 22:13 18 comments

"Only Russia and China can meet American challenge"

Russia and China are the only ones “who can take the challenge of the U.S. in the military field”; others are unable to do it technically, says Ruslan Pukhov from Centre for Analysis of Strategies and Technologies.

02.04.2010, 20:13 10 comments

Russia delivers missile systems to China

Russia has delivered 15 batteries of S-300 surface-to-air missile systems to China. Officials from the National Defense Sector say the deal is unprecedented both in terms of cost and quantity.

17.06.2009, 16:04 5 comments

“Russia and China understand North Korea better”

Russia and China will be first to suffer if something drastic happens in North Korea so they’ll do everything to keep the situation calm there says Andrey Karneev from Institute of Asian and African studies in Moscow.

Vladimir Putin (AFP Photo / RIA Novosti / Pool / Alexey Druzhinin) 14.10.2009, 09:01 5 comments

Russia and China are powerful and peaceful partners – Putin

Prime Minister Vladimir Putin talked to the Chinese media about a number of issues ranging from international politics to bilateral trade, to his personal feelings about chairing Russia’s government.

Chinese forces (AFP Photo / Frederic J. Brown) 23.07.2009, 23:40 4 comments

China, Russia launch large-scale war games

Russian and Chinese military forces are taking part in a five-day joint exercise, one of the biggest of its kind.

28.10.2009, 19:10 4 comments

No S-300 missile shipments to Iran so far – Deputy PM

Russia is not supplying its S-300 air defense missile system to Iran, the country's Deputy Prime Minister Sergey Ivanov has confirmed.

Cam Rahn Bay, Vietnam 06.10.2010, 12:26 8 comments

Russian navy base in Vietnam may be restored

The Russian Navy Command has suggested re-launching a marine logistics base for Russian warships in the Vietnamese deep-water port in Cam Rahn Bay, formerly the largest Soviet base outside the country.

Russian carrier becomes “Made in China” vessel prototype?

Published: 27 October, 2009, 13:03
Edited: 02 May, 2010, 22:21


Russian Federation, Arkhangelsk : Admiral Gorshkov, a Soviet-era aircraft carrier that was bought by India, is anchored in the Sevmash factory in the northern city of Arkhangelsk on July 2, 2009(AFP Photo / Pool / Alexander Zemlianichenko)

If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, then Russia should be very flattered indeed. That’s because China’s new aircraft carrier bears a striking resemblance to an old Russian model.

 
4 COMMENTS
Jim October 27, 2009, 13:37 quote
0

The Chinese are the undisputed masters of 'reverse engineering'. A few years ago the Chinese bought up the MG Rover car company here in the UK and set about dismantling all the machinery for transportation to China. Observers commented on the meticulous attention to detail that the engineers paid to each item, photographing and sketching everything before it was even touched and noteing the smallest detail - down to the oriantation of even tiny screw heads, how many turns each took to unscrew, and using how much torque. This was just the attention to detail that was casually observed - no doubt even further care was taken. Add the above reverse engineering skills to Chinas existing heavy industry experience, existing high technology experience, and the tremendous skills and experience gained in being arguably the largest producer of products for the western market in the world (from computers to cameras, and from car parts to just toys) it is clear the Chinese will be quite capable of producing fully functional versions of others nations products on their own. If China are indeed using old Russian technology as a template don't let that fool you - by starting off with a tried and trusted foundation, any design flaws will have been spotted and improved upon, and the technology fitted will be state of the art. Why start from scratch and spend decades and countless millions developing your 'own' product when you can 'borrow' the best ideas from many different sources and package them together to suit your own needs and buget? Underestimate China at your peril.

Kihnu February 09, 2010, 18:24 quote
+2

The Russian Federation should not be crying too loudly about reverse engineering copies of their weapons by China. Let's not forget that Stalin had his engineers and technicians do the same with the four US B-29s that landed on Soviet territory in 1945. The Soviets copied every piece of the B-29, down to the foot pedals with the Boeing logo. The Russian version of the B-29 became the Tupelov 4 - USSR first '"atomic bomber".

nig February 18, 2010, 09:38 quote
+2

These days it would be foolish to reinvent the wheel. But, machines as complex as an aircraft carrier can not be copied exactly and requires ingenuity of their own, especially the inside workings as mentioned in the video. Countries like India want advanced technologies from countries like Russia to progress militarily and economically such as the recent export attempts of the Brahmos by India.

Justin May 02, 2010, 21:59 quote
+2

China did do licensed production of SU-27s from Russia for sometime using Russian parts. If Russia really had a problem with it, they should have stopped exporting engines to China, as it is the only component that China needs to master. China does not want to become like India or S. Korea dependent on a foreign supplier for one's own defense. Had it continued to license build Su-27, they would make aircrafts at a premium, paying extra for each part in addition to missiles entirely needed b/c of avonics. The frame and exterior is identical but with the advent of the WS-10A you would have almost a different aircraft.

POST COMMENT

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our posting rules


CAPTCHA image