Indian nationalists demand foreign dancers be banned from Bollywood
Published: 05 April, 2010, 10:36
Edited: 12 May, 2010, 08:08
TAGS: Movies, Asia, Human rights, Law
An anti-immigrant political party in India has turned its anger on white actresses working in Bollywood because, as the activists say, local dancers and actresses are losing jobs.
On the other hand, filmmakers claim that foreigners give their movies an international look.
Bollywood is famous for its musicals, and regularly uses foreigners in its dance routines. However, if a local political party has its way, these girls will have to pack their bags very soon.
The Maharashtra Navnirman Sena, or MNS, is a nationalist party that is anti-immigrant and often uses its members to spread its dogma on the streets of Mumbai. It has now called on white foreign actresses to go home.
“Most of these foreign dancers and actresses do not have work permits. They come here on tourist visas,” claimed MNS president Ameya Khopkar. “In case your script demands it, go ahead and use foreigners, but only on valid work permits. But where they are not needed, you must first employ local people.”
“Today Bollywood is one of the best film industries in the world, and you suggest foreigners are better than our people?” exclaimed Khopkar.
The MNS is feared in Bollywood, as it has the power to close cinemas. Party activists recently raided two film sets and demanded to see the work permits of over 100 foreigners. They also allegedly demanded fines from the producers.
However, in a rare case of Bollywood standing up to the MNS, the activists were arrested for extortion.
“We are living in strange times. Globalization means what? Free movement of talent and capital – that is why you call it a global village,” filmmaker Mahesh Bhatt shared his view. “And you cannot create a society that is aspiring to be looking at the global world – and yet allow yourself to gravitate towards that medieval dark value system.”
Nonetheless, many local dancers in Bollywood say they are losing work due to the influx of foreign talent.
“Everywhere you go, on the screen, on the ramp, there are more foreign models than Indians,” complained Bollywood dancer Arva Hussein, “But now it is over the top. Indians are not getting work. Indians should not be compromised for the work of foreign models, actresses or dancers.”
No foreign dancer was willing to talk to RT for fear of being targeted. Bollywood filmmakers say foreigners lack the inhibitions of the more conservative Indian dancers, and also give a film an international look.
“They are professional and they are trimmer. They bring a certain amount of freshness – that is why they have been used repeatedly,” shared Mahesh Bhatt, adding, “And the dancers of yesteryears find no place at all in the scheme of things. So their grievances are understandable, but the world has changed.”
The Indian film industry is now almost a hundred years old, but it could be facing its biggest dilemma yet. Whether or not it retains foreign talent today could well decide if it is to become an international force to reckon with in the future.
05.04.2010, 10:11
4 comments
Police officers killed as blasts shake Southern RussiaTwo police officers have been killed and 13 more injured when two consecutive blasts shook the city of Karabulak in Russia’s Southern Republic of Ingushetia. |
Nursing home head accused of gross mistreatmentThe head of a nursing home in Russia's Far Eastern Republic of Sakha has been charged for putting his elderly clients into a punishment cell and withholding money from their pensions. |
Let us be fair here! There is a great demand for Indians to work in the BPO and restaurant sectors in Europe and the US but there is a cap on the number of work Visas issued each by these countries. If an Indian works in the US, Europe or Russia on a 'Tourist Visa' without a proper work permit and local residents of that country blew the whistle and called in the immigration authorities would RT make out a story in their favour and say "US / European / Russian nationalists ban Indian restaurant workers form serving Tandoori?" Whether it is right or wrong to have such immigration policies in place in any country is debatable but a global reality. However, immigration rules must be followed in every country. RT does not even mention the number of people caught on tourist Visas in the last year working illegally - giving the impression there were none. The MNS guy and the immigration authorities should have been asked that question.
These MNS guys are after money & trying to be 'famous' as their political party lacks support from locals. Few goons are with them . These guys are actually gundas. They are creating issues and common people suffers. As India is having the biggest so called 'democracy' , law is not correctly implemented. In the film industry they are creating issues to take money out from the producers. We can see next week all issues they will solve this issue (after taking some money from producers).












I am quite supportive of the stand taken by MNS on this ban. We have a huge talent pool of good looking actors and actresses right here in Mumbai..I'm sure if you go searching, you'll get thousands of such people within our country who are extremely talented but never get their big break. In a country with a 100Cr+ population, why are we still looking for some white skinned damsels to add that glam quotient to our bollywood movies? Are we stating here that we Indians are not capable of giving that international look and feel to our movies?? I don't understand what globalization Mr Bhatt is talking about...I believe that man has a talent for uttering rubbish at the onset of any given opportunity. Grow up Mr Bhatt...White Skinned People don't add glam quotient to any movies...In fact it looks extremely stupid when we see a La' Salman or an Akshay getting jiggy wiggy with some skinny white chicks in the background... Its time that we started looking at creating opportunities for our own people rather than having some foreigners stealing their bread and butter..It may be fun for these foreigners but for someone in India, it may be their only means of a square meal...