VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Blogs   Katia Zatuliveter   Technocracy vs democracy  
mostpopular
photo_of_the_day
bestvideos

Technocracy vs democracy

Published: 17 November, 2011, 13:00
Edited: 07 May, 2012, 22:36

­I always found technocracy exciting. What a great idea to have a government filled not with politicians, but with people who actually know what they are doing! But is the reality of the technocratic governments as appealing as its theory?

The newly-formed governments of Mario Monti in Italy and Lucas Papademos in Greece have embarked on a journey to find an answer to this question. Both men are economists and were not elected by their people, but through a bureaucratic process on the basis of their specialized knowledge.

They don’t teach it to you in school, but technocracy is an exception to democracy. When democratically-elected leaders make a huge mess out of their countries, it is acceptable for them to be replaced with non-elected professionals for a year or two to get country back into order, so that future elected leaders can start messing it up again.

Both Italy and Greece are familiar with this arrangement very well. For Greece this is the second technocratic government in its history, while for Italy it’s the fourth (!) one in the last 20 years and the second to be brought by the Berlusconi’s reign.

Italy’s three previous technocratic governments lasted from 1992 till 1996, with a short seven-month break, when Berlusconi was first elected after a fierce and successful election campaign. He was forced to leave, but chose his successor personally from his own circle. 

During these four years of technocracy Italy managed to respond effectively to two devaluations of the Lira, the then-Italian currency, thus taking the first steps in the road that brought Italy to adopt the euro.

We constantly hear from various democratic (and not particularly democratic) governments around the world that their 4 to 5-year term was not enough to do what they wanted and therefore they need to be given another chance. These politicians are trying to convince their electorate that unemployment is rising, the healthcare standards are poor and pensions are low because one term in government was not enough to improve the situation. However, the historical examples show that the technocratic governments manage to deal with much bigger problems such as financial crises, devaluation of national currencies, etc in one year. 

The reality, unfortunately, is such that you are either a politician who concentrates all the efforts on getting elected or you are an expert who knows what to do when in government. We should create a new form of government that would be a mixture of democracy and technocracy. We’ll give the politicians a chance to fight elections on behalf of the technocrats who would be left to do the job. The United States would benefit the most from this arrangement, as at the moment politicians spend half of their terms in election campaigns.

­The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of RT.

Back to top
+3 (17 votes)
Camila, March 04, 2012, 08:59
0
interestedany asian girls in south african guys?hey im new in ausartlia, and i wont say there arent many asians in ausartlia, because they really are a lot of asians in ausartlia. so my question is do many japanese people migrate to ausartlia,? see im interested in the japanese cultuure and their people so what do you think my chances are of dating an japanese girl( besides going on dating sites) compared to dating other asian culture, my other question is if there are many asian girls thast like white guys, would they be interested in dating a south african white guy?
canobs, January 16, 2012, 05:24
0
___There is two kinds of Democracy, the REPRESENTATIVE, or Fake one, like in USA (run by lobbeyists, of banks, multinationals and oil and military industry)___And the actually non-existent PARTICIPATIVE or Real one, which would need citizens committees (municipal or regional) participating in all important government decisions (including military and foreign affairs). ___SO, where could we find a Real one, actually nowhere that I know of. ___Sorry for deceiving the dreamers or the Propaganda beleivers.